Earl of Sandwich
“I don't know what about the food is so tasty, but I prefer it to Potbelly's or Quiznos, which I suppose is their competition.”
“The sandwiches are great (can't go wrong with the Tuna Melt), but what sets this place apart is the price.”
“+ Thanksgiving special sandwich – turkey with CRANBERRY and Thanksgiving STUFFING tastes fabulous!”
Earl of Sandwich
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Caters: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
I walked in with a free coupon to try their sandwiches and who doesn't like free?! The nice guy at the register greeted me with enthusiasm and put in a Ham & Swiss for me. Waited max about 5 minutes and took it back to work with me. All I can say is damn is that a good sandwich! It was very simple ham, melted Swiss and honey mustard sauce. The perfect amount of everything. The sandwich wasn't too big or too small and made the perfect size lunch. The prices ran about $5-$6 for a sandwich, which is really reasonable for midtown and the are located right off of 6th Ave on 52nd street. I definitely recommend and because they are so close to my job, I'm definitely going back for more!
Friggin' tasty sandwiches.
Both the Earl's Club and the Original 1762 have taken me through rough times. Recently I scarfed down an Italian – it's got what you'd expect to find in an Italian hoagie – and I have no regrets. Keep in mind that their sandwiches aren't the largest, but they're not the most expensive either. You'll be fed for a few hours.
Earl of Sandwich holds their own against other gourmet shops in the city, especially for a chain. If you've been to their other locations, rest assured this Earl's stays consistent with a smile[1].
If only they were open for dinner Saturdays!
[1] Friendly staff: the guy who made my sandwich knew it was my birthday and wished me a happy one.
What the heck happened to these places? What once used to be the best sandwiches around are now less than mediocre and the menu has shrunk.
Buy a $20 gift card and get $5 free for Xmas, asked if we could use them all at the same time and the answer was yes. Up until the time it came to pay and the couldn't accept the free $5 card with the $20 card I purchased and the manager was to lazy to do a void and start over.
I won't return except to buy 2 waters with my $5 card. There's pizza all over the place, next door too, and I'll stick to that. Sandwiches are not what they used to be.
Had a really good experience at the spot though I never thought I would have. I opted for the build-a-salad with grilled chicken, avocado, chic peas and peppers. The person who made the salad was really helpful.
The cashier and another worker were friendly and they have a soda machine for multiple soda fills ups. This is great if you need to consume a gallon of seltzer with your lunch, as I do.
Pro tip: sign up on their website for their birthday freebie.
I tried the The Montagu after seeing some great yelp pics. I thought it was ok, but nothing great and would not order it again. I think I will return and try another sandwich. The service and sandwich wrapper was impressive.
Was walking out and about and was pleasantly surprised to see this! I honestly thought they were only at Disneyland and Vegas but after a visit to their site, it appears they're in a bunch of other places.
Before I go on, I gotta say, I'm a big fan of Earl of Sandwich! They were a must-visit on Vegas visits, and that only stopped when they opened at Disneyland. So, after I saw this, I decided that I must visit for lunch! I ordered my usual, the Original 1762 with extra horseradish. (Is that weird?) I brought it back to my apartment and chowed down on it. Quality is consistent with their other locations. And isn't that what matters?
If I'm in the area, it's a tough call between this and Halal Guys. But I'm glad that I'm not too far from one if a craving hits me!
great quick lunch or dinner place. had the chicken avocado with chipotle sauce. and a tea. $9 not bad for NYC
pros: everything made while you wait, quick and easy
cons: place needed cleaned and tables were dirty, staff had pants hanging on the ground. yuk
We always go here when we are in Downtown disney so imagine our delight to find one in NYC. The sandwich are always great. Can't wait to go back when I am in Florida.