Potbelly Sandwich Shop

“Love the mediterranean with "light" hot peppers (the peppers are HOT but awesome), the hummus is fantastic.”

“The Wreck (with everything) and Roast Beef sandwiches are very good.”

“p.s. Had the oreo shake which was good but a bit on the sweet side.”

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Caters: Yes

Price range.

$ Price range Under $10

8 reviews

  1. I'm not big on sandwiches in general, but a friend wanted Pot Belly so we dropped by. Was here one afternoon on a weekday … I was surprised by how spacious and clean this place is. I got the Grilled Chicken & Cheddar and it was pretty good. I had the Tuna Salad before from a different location … Taste wise, I felt the Grilled Chicken & Cheddar is so much better. Would I go out of my way for Pot Belly? I don't think so .. But it is a good sandwich option.

  2. I don't know why I keep coming there, I don't really like the sandwiches, it's so basic, the bread tastes like cardboard and there isn't any fun topping… For an extra buck, you can super size…

  3. Overall I like this place and generally come in two or three times per month. It's right next to my favorite coffee shop (Bourbon Coffee) where I spend a lot of time in order to avoid anxiety-riddled law students. If I'm hungry, I pop into Potbelly for a quick sandwich before I head into the coffee shop for a caffeine fix.

    FOOD: definitely a couple steps above a typical lunchtime experience, but still a step or two below restaurant quality and the options are a bit limited. I've had a couple of the sandwiches on the menu (the Italian and the turkey sandwich), and they've all been quite tasty and fresh. They run it through the oven when you order it, so it always comes out nice and hot. You can order sandwiches as arranged on the menu or make your own (though making your own will probably be a bit more expensive than what's offered on the menu). They also have shakes and other fare, but I've yet to indulge in those. You also have your choice of condiments and/or other ingredients like lettuce, tomato, etc. Pretty standard fare in that department. Always very filling.

    SERVICE: unlike many NYC lunch places, the service here has consistently been quite excellent. They get your food to you quickly and they're always very pleasant. I was actually taken aback the first time I came in because I'm not used to that kind of service during lunch.

    PRICES: this is where Potbelly stumbles a bit. The sandwiches, alone, tend to run $6-$7. If you opt for anything else and a drink, you're quickly looking at a $10+ meal. Part of what's deterred me from the shakes and other options is the fact that I'd easily be up to $10 or beyond at that point, and I generally like getting lunch for $5-$6 (I'm a big deli patron during lunchtime). It would be nice to see some kind of a "combo" option that would give you a bit of a discount on an entire meal. Whenever I come in I just get the sandwich and skip the rest.

  4. I'm underwhelmed. Mostly by the lack of sandwich and salad selection (especially for someone who prefers healthy and/or non-meat). But also, what's up, service? Why aren't you there anymore?

    I feel like there really isn't a reason that it should take *so long* to get a sandwich right. Or get the soup served. There is just something missing with the system.

    Overall, this is a decent lunch spot if you don't need to make it too quick and you love meat of all kinds. For others, walk on.

  5. Good ol' Potbelly's. The pizza sandwich hits the spot on a cold, rainy afternoon and you always feel good walking out afterwards.

  6. Sandwiches are good. If you read the fine print at the bottom of the menu, there are options beyond the signature sandwiches, so you can pretty much order any combination of meats and toppings you'd like.

    WARNING: the peppers are actually really spicy– and I can tolerate a good amount of heat. On these sandwiches however, I usually end up taking the majority of the peppers off because they're so overpowering, you can't taste anything else.

    That being said, I actually don't even go to Potbelly for the sandwiches, but rather the milkshakes. The chocolate malt is *fire emoji.* I like them better here than any other place in the city, and for $3.50 the price is better than everywhere else too.

  7. Oh my gosh I was so pissed the day that I walked in here specifically for a milkshake only to find out that they weren't selling milkshakes THAT DAY. I went out of my way to go there. There was one close to my job but this location was closer to my destination. I was so hurt. I had to get a McDonalds milkshake! A MCDONLADS MILKSHAKE!!!! :-O *real tears*

  8. I REALLY LOVE Potbelly Sandwiches.

    Better than Subways? YUP

    Better than your favorite bagel shop? YUP

    Better than what you make at your house? NOPE

    But especially if you are craving a well made sandwich, this is where I'd go. I always go for the chicken with cheddar and turkey. Both in the large size because Asians can eat. That is not a myth, it's a fact. The premium toppings aren't really worth it in my opinion but if you had to add on something that you are paying an extra 60 cents for, go for artichoke. It's healthier for you. Otherwise, stick with the free ones.

    Price is comparable to their Financial District location. More expensive than Subways yes but quality also better.

    FAN.

Rate and write a review

West 14th Street 41
New York 10011 NY US
Get directions
Monday, 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
Tuesday, 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
Wednesday, 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
Thursday, 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
Friday, 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
Saturday, 11:00 am - 7:00 pm
Sunday, 11:00 am - 7:00 pm