Toasties
“I hear legends about the Thanksgiving sandwich (everything you can imagine from Thanksgiving on a bun -or biscuit?), but I have never been brave enough to try it.”
“I noticed alot of the reviews mentioned the long wait times so I conveniently picked a day when most people wouldn't be at work.”
“Seriously, the lines move so fast when there are any, and the salads are the best of any "create your own" that I've had at a spot like this in Midtown.”
Toasties
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Outdoor Seating: Yes
Caters: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range $11-30
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Today I tried one of Toasties breakfast wraps and it was delicious! I got the Los Huevos wrap and it was awesome. It was a decent portion and it was $5. I would definitely get breakfast from them again. It is affordable, fresh, and yummy!
Completely forgot the fact that two days ago it was national sandwich day; never say too late so I went up to toasties to get my sandwich.
Great variety of selections, serving either hot or cold, Toasties was simply the perfect place to visit if you are a sandwich guy. Got the spicy chicken sandwich with whole wheat bread – liked the crispy bread and the hot sauce, very tasty.
Waiting time can get really nasty here -coming during off-hours did not guarantee a quick delivery, so be prepared.
I get my breakfast here due to the close proximity to my job. I have also had the soups here which are decent. Overall, the food is decent-they are rather pricey (I guess everything in Midtown is) also they have a $5 minimum for credit and debit cards. The workers are usually friendly, but the long wait time is usually pretty long.
I will continue to come here, but solely out of conveinience.
After being relocated by my job to midtown east, my new coworkers recommended Toasties for their salads and sandwiches. So finally the day before Thanksgiving, I finally gave it a try. I noticed alot of the reviews mentioned the long wait times so I conveniently picked a day when most people wouldn't be at work.
I tried their classic chicken sandwich which I really did enjoy. The chicken was still pretty moist and i'm such a sucker for melted mozzarella and roasted red peppers. It's pretty typical midtown prices. Sandwich plus a drink was around $11.
The sandwiches are pretty good here, but they're just "pretty good." I don't think that my sandwich made up for the price I paid for it.
I think you can find better quality sandwiches are more boutique delis however.
A lot of healthful and great looking breakfast and lunch items. I sat outside and had one of their egg white breakfast wraps… highly recommended. It was also priced very reasonably.
Tasty sandwiches although pretty heavy. Ordering, paying and collecting can sometimes be a bit of a shamble but it is worth it!
Their highly raved hot pastrami and corned beef sandwich was completely ruined by over-dose on the Russian dressing. The bread roll was half-heartedly soggy.
Not to mention the service was bad… Also, the shop has interior design issues – what the heck going on with the window by those seats? You sit there but you have NO VIEW just wall…
One most important takeway on the sandwiches: stop using TOO MUCH dressing on food! we are not there to drink your dressing, but to eat your food, at the minimum, would you please explicitly say the dressing level in the sandwich is controllable?
I ended up throwing this overpriced $9 sandwich away, went to the Subway next door and grabbed a Spicy Italian on whole wheat. Guess what, it was A LOT BETTER!