Super Hero Sub Shop
“The delivery guy was super nice and definitely deserved his tip unlike all the nasty delivery guys I have encountered.”
“Both times I ordered my usual, oven roasted turkey, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, jalapeños, mayo, salt, pepper, oil, and vinegar on a small roll.”
“Just surpassed Blimpie as my favorite sandwich spot.”
Super Hero Sub Shop
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Caters: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
4 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Maybe it's because I'm Italian, but I don't understand the stellar reviews. First – a note about the 'hood. It's reasonably close to the big office spots around JSQ, but it isn't the best area. I'm not typically in this area, and I'd advise against it if you live elsewhere or don't hit this area up for work on occasion. Now, onto the food. I had a salad and a sandwich. The salad was actually very good but shockingly small for ~$7. The Caesar dressing was a vinegarette instead of creamy which was another plus. The Sub was very large and substantially cheaper than the salad (again — weird, usually the other way around). I was super disappointed with the quality of the turkey :(. It was that cold, slimey super processed stuff you can get in those red tubs near the lunchables at the grocery store. I was shocked! I took more of the turkey off and ate the cheese and veggies which were standard. Turkey eaters — skip the turkey here! I've had better turkey from Subway. This was not authentic North Jersey deli quality meat!!! Also — they forgot to include my water with my order. This spot is definitely not worth the trek from downtown unless you happen to be in the neighborhood for work.
This place is great! Really nice people, freshly sliced deli meats and cheeses, consistent and friendly delivery, and delicious tasting wraps and sandwiches. I generally order a turkey and pepper jack wrap. I've been to the store a couple of times and ordered delivery more time than I should. You can taste the freshness and I have seen them slice the ingredients to order when I've been there in person. I've gone there near closing time and they didn't rush and made sure I was happy with what I got. My only complaint is they often seem to be out of different things. But they actually call you to tell you this if you order delivery as opposed to most places who will just leave things out. Panini I ordered once wasn't that great and the salads are alright but nothing special. Stick to the wraps and sandwiches and you will be happy.
First things first, delivery took a significant amount of time, approximately an hour and forty minutes. I called and was told that our order went out last and that the driver had six orders overall. Mind you, this was already an hour into the wait time. By the time the order arrived, the panini and "hot" roast beef sandwich were luke warm at best and needed to be reheated. The grilled cheese panini tasted no better than a grilled cheese I could've cooked up in five minutes. The chicken salad sandwich, while certainly large and admittedly inexpensive for its size (about 11 bucks), was middle of the road. The plus was that it wasn't too drowned in mayo. Finally the roast beef also was very average. At best, I would describe SuperHero Sub Shop as 'Superman Returns'. Well meaning but not doing the genre justice (and career ending for Brandon Routh).
Seriously, I'm a firm believer In trying a place a few times before leaving a poor review. I would advise that to the Yelpers below, because I don't believe that those are issues that are so unbearably unfixable, unless an establishment fucks up royally. See my review for Sloppy Joe's – that was a cause for a riot and a first time crap review.
I really have to commend this place because we've ordered here before (a ton of times) and after a MINOR mishap, I messaged the business privately through yelp, and one of the owners immediately called to apologize and offered a form of compensation. Customer service (on top of the really nice girls in the store) is really commendable here. I really didn't expect to be offered to be compensated, as I only wanted to express my grievances with this ONE instance and to offer some suggestions, but it was really a nice gesture.
These guys have a good thing going on. Again, their ingredients are fresh and tasty. Also, their brother business, Fatties, is REALLY good too.
Thanks again, sub shop, for the attentiveness to your customers! It really goes a long way. I'll definitely keep coming back!