Gotham City Diner
“I especially love it because I am a Batman fan and it is fun experience to eat in "gotham."”
“Matzo ball soup and salads are excellent!”
“My most recent visit, i had ordered their Santa Fe Benny – Chorizo hash and eggs benedict with chipotle hollandaise – from the egg benedicts menu.”
Gotham City Diner
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range $11-30
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Came for brunch on a Tuesday. This diner is located right on Route 4, with plenty of parking. It's large, clean, and they have an ice cream counter and dessert bar. Our waitress, Jackie, was very friendly, even though we were a little slow to order. She also came by with drink refills very quickly.
I ordered the corned beef hash and eggs. it was very standard, nothing special. But they did burn my corned beef hash as I had asked. Home fries were a little different than the standard since they seemed to be made with red potatoes, which was nice. The prices are actually much lower than the other diners in the area, which was surprising.
My food was quite bland… As I suspected it would be.
This place doesn't exceed the late night diner expectation.
I ordered a chicken sandwich on a pretzel bun and it was soooo tateless!
BBQ Cobb salad was delicious. Portion size is very generous and the service was great. I would definitely eat here again in their diner style booths.
A great variety of choices at a reasonable price! I've tried their Bari wrap and smoked salmon benny, and I've loved them both. I've tried a few other dishes too, but I can't remember them at the top of my head.
When my boyfriend and I feel like going out to eat but don't feel like spending much money or driving more than 10 minutes, this is our go-to.
Lots of misses, this place has changed. I really hope the quality of food picks back up.
Not your average diner! The decor is really unique and they have a large selection of food options. Service is pretty average but food is delicious. Try the Carolina dry rub wings!
Our Waitress was fantastic! HOWEVER, the diner is not very clean. The coffee mug I was given was filthy! It definitely wasn't cleaned properly. The menus stuck to each other and were disgusting, I didn't even want to touch it. Once our food came out, there were flies all around us. The food wasn't thoroughly cooked. I mean come on.
It's sad to say but I will never come to eat here again. The location is convenient and the diner itself is nice but the diner needs attention. Management needs to be aware of this. Your diner has gone to crap since the last time I've been here with my family.
I was born and raised in NJ, and I've definitely visited my fair share of diners. I have to say that Gotham City Diner does not qualify as a Jersey diner to me. I really don't love their food at all even if I'm not judging it on Jersey diner standards. Everything I've ever had here has always been just a tad over done-dried out omelets, over toasted bread etc. I would rather visit other local diners instead. I do have to give them props though-there is a salad on their menu that has strawberries and goat cheese in it and it's actually very enjoyable. Of course, no cooking is involved in making a salad so it's impossible for it to be overdone.