Sarabeth’s at Chelsea Market

Sarabeth’s at Chelsea Market

Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes

Price range.

$$ Price range Moderate

2 reviews

  1. Not bad at all.

    Super, hecka, hella sweet creme brûlée. Served chilled, moist texture– almost too moist & pudding like. Torched layer– super sweet, but good.

    I prefer creme brûlée less pudding like and thicker when it comes to the custard. It was a little more liquidy than I prefer.

    Also had a chocolate cake. It was ehhhh. Wouldn't recommend or get again. Kinna dry.

    Elephant short bread cookie = very tasty. I'd go without the frosting.

    Overall, not bad, but wouldn't really come back. Also, very touristy.

    From the Filipina foodie in NYC,
    Renee Rises

  2. This is a nice addition to Chelsea Market! I stopped in and got a small coffee, a pineapple almond tart, and a small elephant ear. Everything was really delicious but nothing stood out as particularly special to me. I'm only familiar with Sarabeth's various jams and jellies so maybe I didn't order the right items.

    They offer a variety of breads and pastries including cookies, scones, muffins, biscuits, macaroons, rugelach, and tarts. They also have a menu listing their selection of salads and sandwiches. Besides coffee, they also offer a number of teas. Despite this selection, they have very limited seating including one communal table and a handful of 2-tops.

    From the outside, you can watch the bakers hard at work. After seeing this, my mother and I decided to go in and check out their pastries. It was all delicious, and I think I would go in again. However, I think I might try something else – like their blueberry tart or one of their cookies.

Rate and write a review

9th Avenue 75
New York 10011 NY US
Get directions