Petee’s Pie Company
“I LOVE this PIE….from the chocolate chess to the cherry to the coconut and the pie crust is incredible.”
“I ordered my Thanksgiving pies from Petee's Pie Company and was thoroughly impressed.”
“Petee's is a cute little pie shop (with coffee, tea, ice cream, etc) off Delancey with only 5 bar stools at a counter against the window.”
Petee’s Pie Company
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Accepts Apple Pay: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Caters: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Banana cream pie. Creamy. Delicious. It was recommended to me by the cashier and it was a yummy treat. So many different pies and flavors to choose from, there's definitely one for everybody! Can't wait to come back and get my pie-on!!!
Best pie I've ever had and the Parlor coffee is amazing too. If I could live off this pie, I would die a fatty.
Recommend:
Apple Pie
Blueberry Pie
Colombia single-origin
I recently had the pleasure of having a piece of their NY Cheesecake. It was some of the best I've ever had.
The orange zest in the crust was a wonderful surprise. The texture was silky, rich and smooth. The crust was crispy, buttery and delicious.
I'm eager to come back and try more pies!
I love blueberry pie! Such a hole in the wall and everything looks amazing. The blueberry pie was not sweet at all and that is exactly how I liked it! The crust was also pretty good and everything tasted fresh. Not much of a sit down place and although a bit out of the way for me…. I'd come back just to pick up a pie or something.
My stepbrother treated my wife and I on our recent visit to New York City to a piece of pie for our anniversary. There seem to be a lot of options so I hopefully you are one that can make up your mind. I think you can never go wrong with the Pecan pie with whipped cream on it. I think the price is $6-$7 with a dollar extra for whipped cream. It's definitely a pretty expensive if you multiply that out for a whole pie but this is New York City so it's to be expected. I am kind of glad I don't have a place like this close to me so I'm not always tempted to try new pieces of pie. It's definitely worth at least one stop if you have a sweet tooth.
Such a cute place!! My boyfriend has been craving pie (and I mean real, delicious pie) for the longest time but I've never been able to find anything remotely great via my Yelp searching…until my best friend brought us here tonight! I really don't know what it is about these pies that make them so tasty, for I really only got 2-3 bites of the chocolate slice that I ordered. I am truly satisfied and oh, the coconut one was good too.
Advice for any Yelper or non-yelper: on a rainy night when you're still hungry after a dinner out with friends, fill your stomach up with pie from Petee's! Another advantage to having come here? Now I know what to do for birthdays; no more frustration and head scratching over picking out the perfect cake…just get them a good old pie 🙂
I love pie. But, during the summer months, I can't bring myself to turn on the oven when its 95 degrees out. This is where the great Petee's comes in to save the day. They have seasonal pies, ice box pies, meringue pies and even cheesecake (while it isn't a pie they do make a great cheesecake). I'd highly recommend their peach pie and key lime pie! Gotta go back to try more the next time I'm in the neighborhood.
OMG. The role model for what all pies should be.
Literally. close your eyes. think of what a blueberry pie should taste like. That's exactly what Petee's tastes like. Not sour, not too sweet – and fresh AF. Seriously the blueberry pie is wonderful and has changed me for life. Careful cutting the slices, things can get messy! The crust falls apart but who cares this pie is glorious.
The apple pie is delicious but didn't wow me as much as the blueberry did. Same with the salty chocolate chess pie. The salty chocolate pie had the consistency of mousse yet tasted like a brownie. I know this sounds delicious and it totally was, but the blueberry still beat it.