City Diner
“This is one of the last of the classic diners that for so many years were a mainstay on the UWS.”
“The inside has an art deco decor and there is not much more I can say.”
“I've been to most of the diners on the Upper West Side.”
City Diner
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range $11-30
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
This review could really be just one word: Lumberjack. And no, it's not about husky men with beards (which I also have a thing for, but that's a different story). The Lumberjack is the superstar of the all-day breakfast offerings here. It's a stack of plate-sized fluffy pancakes, two eggs and every type of breakfast meat you can think of — a lovely griddled sausage link, a pile of crispy bacon, a slice of ham. Mmmmm. If you are after a breakfast feast, get a Lumberjack.
We dined here twice… the first time I got french toast with eggs and sausage. Delicious. But my friend got the Lumberjack and I had ordering envy. The second time we ate here, I did not make the same mistake. But apparently I was so busy eating that I did not take a photo of the Lumberjack. Sorry, friends. You'll have to use your imaginations. #yelpfail
The City Diner itself is a pretty standard 24-hour diner with a bit of New York flair. It seems like a place that could serve as a set for a movie set in the 50s or 60s… We really picked it because it was on the way home and offered 24-hour breakfast. The food was good and definitely met the need. Service was fine. We even took some muffins to go for the morning, and those were very good as well. All in all, a good place to stop for a quick bite, with a bonus star for all-day breakfast and that Lumberjack.
I have been here a few times for their breakfast. Anytime I am in New York, I love going here for their breakfast menu. It is convenient and a wonderful experience.
I love the decor of this place. It has a slight 50's ring to it without going too deep into the decade. It reminds me of a small town diner with an urban twist (best way I can put it).
The employees appear to do great at keeping everything clean. Of all the times I have visited, I have never once had an issue with cleanliness nor order. Therefore, I always feel comfortable anytime I am here.
The employees here are always friendly, and they appear to know how to do their jobs well. They appear to always be on top of their duties. They are almost always busy so they often do not have time for conversation, which is not a big deal. However, they are helpful with suggestions and questions I may have.
The food here is delicious! This place never fails to impress me, no matter what I order. This is one of the few places where I like to try different things most of the time that I am here. My favorite plate here is the common breakfast ensemble (I forget the name of it). I do not think I have ever had to wait any longer than five minutes for my plate to be served to me, which is rare with my experience of restaurants.
The prices are reasonable, considering the quality and quantity of what I get. It is refreshing that I can get a good quality breakfast without breaking the bank.
When I am in New York and looking for good breakfast, I will continue checking out this place. This place never fails to please.
Breakfast is pretty good here. But what sets City Diner apart is the welcoming atmosphere and good service.
Their City Fritata is delicious and even though I always say I will try something else I always end up ordering this dish!
Came in late with a couple of friends. Diner is clean and well lit. Staff is nice and fast. We ordered and the food came out super quick. I had a burger deluxe medium rare – it tasted great and was a good size burger. My friend got pancakes and french toast – they were very happy as well. As far as new york diners go this is a win. I am sure we will be back as this place was just great! Prices very good and even great for the area!!!
City Diner is a no fuss, delicious, hearty staple. You can get just about anything–it is a diner after all–at any hour, and you will be satisfied. While it is not as cheap as some diners, given the neighborhood, the prices are extremely reasonable. Food is always fresh, service is quick, portions are big, and I've never had a bad experience after countless takeout and drop ins. A favorite for sure.
i used to come here while I visited my grandmother in the nursing home which is a little disheartening but City Diner changed that! they offer big, heart plates that are super fresh. the service is great as well. I definitely recommend the Organic Field of dreams salad with a fresh Norweigan salmon fillet and berries and the Fettuccine Genovese with thick dices of chicken and mushroom and pesto.
Great 24/7 diner on the Upper West Side. Food is pretty good & the feel is pretty comfy though not the most modern looking place. You can hang out here without getting hassled at night, which is a great thing. Service is decent enough. I'd recommend it if you were in this area.
Standard diner fare. Popular with a lot of locals and always has people eating at all hours of the day and night. Don't expect fancy food but the corned beef hash, burgers, and slices of pie are perfectly decent for a late night snack!