Halal Cart
“It is a pleasure to have such a good halal cart right next to MSG/Penn station.”
“Was on the verge of starving to death when I smelt something delightful~ looked it up on Yelp, as I always do and decided on chicken rice.”
“I got the chicken and rice with white and red sauce and a drink for 6 dollars!!!!”
Halal Cart
Take-out: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Outdoor Seating: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
3 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
I was teetering between 3 and 4 stars since this establishment is a solid 3.5 stars and an excellent place for a quick bite if you are on the go awaiting a train/bus near Penn Station. The Halal Guys have set the bar fairly high for chicken/rice in NYC so unfortunately any halal cart will have to compete with them with my taste buds being the judge. First off, it looks like there hasn't been a review for this place in quite some time so I will say that contrary to prior reviews the price has been upped by 1 dollar (6 bucks flat) for the chicken/rice plate which comes with a generous amount of of protein, seasoned rice (spicy rice available on request per other reviews), small side salad of iceberg lettuce/sliced tomatoes, and your choice of a white mayonnaise based sauce and red vinegary pepper sauce similar to buffalo wing sauce.
Pros:
Convenience- right at front entrance of Penn Station
Flavor-interesting flavor accents on request such as olives and hot peppers and random bits of broccoli and green peppers
Value- at a dollar more still a bargain meal for the portions given
Service- the person manning the cart was very cordial and applied the sauces at the end with a little showman-like flare which I appreciated
Cons
No menu with posted prices other than random photos displayed on the cart itself
I'm more of a traditionalist so would rather the white sauce be yogurt-based and the red sauce be closer to harissa since the sauces described above along with the choice of stir-fried broccoli adds a distinct Western accent that could be good/bad depending on personal preference
At the end of the day, I would still choose this cart over any retail fast-food option if I'm in the area, but let's be clear, they're no The Halal Guys.
This halal cart is located just across the street from Jimmy's BBQ on the Northeast corner of 31st St. and 8th Ave. The man inside the cart archaically takes orders from all his customers in every which way, rather than taking the orders of the next one or two standing in line. I guess this makes his cooking more efficient as he can portion how much food to throw on the grill, but he asked us 2-3 times what we ordered. For the most part, this cart is standard-fare serving lamb off a doner kebab and chicken. However, I also noticed there long whole sausages sitting adjacent to the grill that I was quite intrigued about. But to keep things safe, I ordered Lamb over Rice ($5.00), which you have the option of yellow or spicy rice. I opted for the spicy rice along with white and hot sauce.
As we waited, I watched the chef as he chopped up the lamb meat very fine into small bits and squirted a red liquid on it to moisten it up. Thumbs up for that, which helps make the meat a little more tender and tasty. He then scooped a couple spoonfuls of rice and put the standard chopped lettuce and sliced tomatoes in. He then squirted, what seemed like for 5-6 seconds of the white sauce, and then some hot sauce. It was doused completely in white sauce. Usually the white sauce helps accentuate the flavors but I was hoping it wouldn't turn out to be eating practically all mayo. When opening the container, I noticed that portions were fairly large, almost twice the amount of meat that I've been recently accustoming myself from other halal carts in the area. One could make the claim that the meat was so finely chopped to give the appearance of a lot of meat, but I'd have to say there actually was. The lamb meat was indeed moist and flavorful; not too salty and not too bland, but just right. The white sauce, of the mayo variation, was pretty standard as well as the hot sauce which I didn't find spicy at all. Where I found a kick was from the rice, which used a fatter/wider grain as opposed to the longer-grained basmati rice. One of my friends claimed that it tasted like Goya rice. However, the spicy variation did indeed have some heat initially, but then it got overpowered with a vinegar-like flavor. It kept reminding me of Frank's Hot Sauce, or when you eat so many of the typical buffalo wings and your lips start to get numb from that vinegar flavor. After a while, my palate was overpowered from that sourness that I had to take a couple breaks while eating.
At the end of the day, it was pretty good as the meat portions helped justify much of the smiles on my face. I will probably settle for their regular rice, which the 5-6 other people on line had ordered, as the spicy rice was just too overbearing. Another thing worth noting is that he will also offer olives and hot peppers, both from two humongous glass jars, which is a nice bonus if you so desire. For $5, it's not the worst in the neighborhood, but it's also not the best.
Typical NYC halal food cart. I would have preferred for the seasoning to have a little more cumin but with a little less turmeric and nutmeg. The portions and prices are on par with the other carts.