Best Lexington Pizza

“Delivery is consistently fast and somehow each time I order rice, my go to dish, they manage to pack in more than the previous time.”

“Their rotisserie chicken (Pollo a la Brasa) is consistenly tender and juicy and I would especially recommend it with their spicy green sauce.”

“Simple,good,fair price, and i like the fact that i am supporting a local family owned business of which i must say- The owners are Awesome people!”

Best Lexington Pizza

Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes

Price range.

$$ Price range $11-30

4 reviews

  1. Now THAT'S what I call a hidden gem.  The name of this business gives absolutely no clue as to what it does best: Peruvian food! The whole chicken is the best we're had, juicier and more flavorful than Pio Pio and Flor de Mayo.  The delivery person has one of those insulated bags so the food arrived incredibly hot. The Peruvian fried rice was also delicious.  My wife thought it was a bit too salty, though. The green sauce that comes with the chicken is a little thicker and spicier than what I've had previously. I have no idea if their pizza is good, but really, who cares?

  2. The full name of this place is "Best Lexington Pizza & Peruvian Food". I did not try the pizza, but the Peruvian food is actually not bad  and authentic. I chose the Tallarin Salteado, which I'd never had before. It was similar to Lomo Salteado (which I have had) except it has spaghetti instead of rice. It was very tasty – pieces of steak stir fried with onions and tomatoes. It had a nice strong garlic taste to it. The portion was a little smaller than I would have liked but that is because I am a pig. It was great washed down with an Inca Kola. They have pollo a la brasa too.

  3. I was in the mood for some vegetables one night and I decided to try a new place. I found the menu for Best Lexington Pizza and saw the pasta with veggies on there. I ordered the penne with red sauce and veggies with chicken, and I was really blown away by the quality considering this is a "pizza place."

    The pasta was cooked just right, the sauce wasn't overly sweet (so common!) and was nice and tangy, and THE VEGGIES! Holy mackerel. I love fresh veggies and I rarely order vegetables for take out because they are usually over cooked/boiled/blah. This pasta came loaded with fresh broccoli, peppers, etc, and it was all cooked just right – still with a little crunch and sautéed lightly. There was breaded chicken on the bottom that soaked up the sauce and was lovely.

    This was a simple meal, but it really blew me away for delivery food. Also – it was cheap!

    Summary: Delicious pasta with FRESH veggies, and good prices. Absolute repeat.

  4. I order Peruvian food from this place a lot and always wanted to try the Papas a la huanicaina. Finally today I did, and I gotta say I was very disappointed. It looked so good in the picture, but it's basically boiled potatoes with the yellow sauce on top and half a boiled egg for $7! I could kill for some salt and pepper right now, it's so bland! And they forgot to put the bed of lettuce underneath the potatoes, which would've made it look nicer. I'm not sure if this is the authentic way to have this dish in Peru but I think considering the ingredients it shouldn't be $7.00.

    I hate giving bad reviews, especially because this place is on point with their chicken! And the owner is as nice person, but I won't be getting this dish again 🙁

    I wish I could only review this one dish I'd give it 0 stars, but like I said they have amazing other dishes like the chicken and green Peruvian sauce.
    So this 1 star is only for the papas a la huanicaina.

Rate and write a review

Lexington Avenue 1634
New York 10029 NY US
Get directions
Monday, 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Tuesday, 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Wednesday, 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Thursday, 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Friday, 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Saturday, 11:00 am - 11:00 pm