Vinnie’s Pizzeria
“This is unquestionably the greatest (specialty) pizza place in NYC, and by extension planet Earth.”
“My favorite is the vegan mac attack, but I also recommend the black bean burrito slice, and the barbecue chicken slice.”
“The joint was busy but the guys working at the front were all really nice, and tried to work it as fast as they could–and I think that was just fine.”
Vinnie’s Pizzeria
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
PokéStop Nearby: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
My favorite place. Highly recommend the avocado quesadilla pizza. And the staff is awesome
Vinnie's, of "OMG PIZZA BOX MADE OF PIZZA" fame is known for their plethora of combination slices and abundant toppings. I only like plain or pepperoni pizza. Maybe Vinnie's is not for me.
Vinnie's has a really good crust, as it's really nice and thin, the way a typical NY slice should be. However, my opinion is that they use too many herbs, particularly basil, and that ruins the balance of flavor for me.
Don't get me wrong, I would certainly come back here, but I wouldn't prioritize it over Joe's, which is just a little further down Bedford Ave.
LEGIT
So I was drawn into this place, I don't know what it was, but something told me I had to go in.
They have all this rad pizza art all over, but it's still definitely divey. I had no idea what I wanted, and the guy working was super nice and told me all the different options I had instead of being annoyed that I didn't know what I wanted.
I ended up getting the special of the day, which was the grandpa sriraza – holy moly!!! It was so freaking good. I ate so much this day I didn't plan on having the whole slice, but I finished the dang thing.
Limited seating, so some random couple asked to sit in my booth with me, which of course I let them….but slightly awkward.
Vinnie's totally has a place in my heart now, and it's one of the few places I'd have to go back to again in NY.
My friend and I wandered here craving pizza after we weren't really satisfied with the dinner we just ate. From the outside, it looks like your typical small pizza take out place. However, once you get to the counter, you'll once again learn that looks are deceiving.
There are so many unique options here and the employees are so friendly! If you ask for recommendations, you'll be told a variety of options, making the decision of ordering just one slice that much more difficult. In the end, my friend and I went with the meatball slice and ate it outside in the cold as seating is limited.
If you're in the area and want a quick bite, get the meatball slice! The crust is just as great too!
This was my first experience of authentic Brooklyn pizza, and they didn't disappoint. The place is simple but honest with comfortable but limited seating. The food was excellent- we got a meatball hero sandwich (big eat- you were warned!) and a pepperoni pizza- both delicious. Prices are pretty good for the quality you're getting.
I think this is the most Williamsburgy place I've been to in awhile. Retro 80's and 90's memorabilia on the wall, a clear love of puns, vegan pizza (oy), slow moving skinny hipsters both in front of and behind the counter. I overheard the following conversation, "Don't you think it's interesting that Philadelphia erected a statue to Rocky Balboa? He's not even a REAL PERSON".
Anyway, the pizza is fine. I'm not too into their plain slices, but the eggplant and ricotta slice was actually really good. I'd eat again, but I wouldn't make this a destination. The space is standard pizzeria sized, with just four booths. Service was good.
Randomly craved pizza and luckily for me, this was the place I decided on.
You walk in and it kind of had a Chinese Take-Out restaurant feel which isn't a bad thing at all! You grab your pizza, and sit in the benches and enjoy.
Unfortunately, I wasn't able to snap a photo of the white pizza slice I ordered, I was just THAT hungry, and it smelled amazing!
Just by looking at the pizza I could already tell that first bite was going to be crisp and flavorful. It had small plops of ricotta cheese and little pieces of basil on each plop (cute), and don't even get me started with the crust!
I don't know how they're making that dough, but they're making it right.
Not bad. Vegan options which I was surprised they had. I would come back again but ask that they heat the pizza up more. Didnt want my date to think i was prissy for asking for my pizza to be warmer.
Two slices. The eggplant slice and the spicy slice. The eggplant was really good. The slice could have donw without the ziti. I cant wait to come back to Vinnies to try some other vegan slices an non vegan ones.