Best Pizza
“I like it better than Roberta's, Motorino and Paulie Gee's. You don't have to bear the long waits and they always play great 90s hip hop.”
“The pizza here is delicious the name deft suits this pizza joint right.”
“Once again Brooklyn delivers on serving up fresh tasty pizza that makes you want to forego any summer beach bod goals.”
Best Pizza
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Best Pizza! It's a pretty bold statement to make yourself the "Best" pizza…when New Yorkers bleed marinara!!
I recently read the "Slice Harvester" by Colin Antrophy Hangendorf. The man ate a slice of pizza at every Manhattan pizza establishment! A great food memoir and a funny read. I can't commit myself to eat so much pizza. However, I do have to say that pizza is one of my favorite food groups! It's got everything you want in one delicious slice.
I'm pescatarian and in my book the more veggies the better. And Best Pizza does just that. They don't hold back in the pizza mentality…corn..sure, why not, kale, potato!? and yeah…radishes. It's like an "everything but the kitchen sink" veggie pizza slice. And I'm thrilled! I love all veggies! And to have all my faves on one slice is incr-edible!! Be warned it's a square slice and much thicker than the regular slices.
I'm also a huge fan of the white pizza with dollops of caramelized onions. The minimum on cards in $10. So two slices and an ice cold Peroni ($5) will get you to $13 and a very full belly!
The space has nice window booths and a couple tables and yet it can be tough to find a spot to sit at. I wish they had a wrap-around counter or if they worked with a bar to have pizza. Hint..hint. Still a great family spot.
I spotted garlic knots last time I was here and they are next to be devoured by this muchacha! I can already smell the garlicky morsels!
Keep up the good work Best Pizza! See you soon!! My mouth thanks you, my pants…not so much!
I finally tried best pizza…what is a the fuss about?!?! Go to Anna Maria's or Joes if you're in Williamsburg instead.
Came here on a weekday afternoon so the place was pretty empty and hence 2min wait for our pizza – 2 slices of cheese and 1 slice of grandma. The crust was just amazing, best I've ever had tbh. A bit on the pricey side but worth the buck. My friend who used to swear by Joe's as the best pizza in NYC converted to the dark side of Best Pizza afterward. I've read raving reviews on their white pizza as well which I'll make sure to try at my next visit. Decor is really interesting unlike the typical pizzeria – a mix between coffee shop and tattered eccentric thrift store. Not sure about wifi but I saw power outlets above the bench seats! Also got self-serve water and condiments. Really cool spot and awesome pizza, can't wait to come back.
We were visiting Brooklyn for a show. I typed in "Best Pizza In Brooklyn" in google and it, of course, brings up this place, that is actually called "Best Pizza". Genius. We walk over and down a few blocks and go in. It's a small place, covered in paper plates with drawings all over them. The guys working the counter were really cool and welcoming.
I ordered a cheese pizza and when it came out I was in amazement. I think we all were. Just that "Oooooh" Ahh" factor. The slices were as big as my head, as New York style pizza should be.
All I can say is that this is the best cheese pizza I have ever had, and my friends and I still talk about it all the time. Next time we're back in Brooklyn, we will defiantly be back here.
I'm glad that they live up to their name.
Maybe it's because I was drinking, but this place really lives up to it's name–one of the best slices of pizza. The sauce was flavorful, cheese ratio was perfect, pepperoni slices were massive and a slight hint of fresh basil. Yummmm.
Food: 4.0/5.0
Service: 3.0/5.0
Value: 2.5/5.0
Decor: 2.5/5.0
Overall: 4.0/5.0
This place serves a pretty good New York slice, but I would generally concur with others that it's a bit over-rated. Crust was good, the single basil leaf garnishing the slices was perhaps a nice try (but admittedly felt a bit contrived), and the cheese was meh. I typically wouldn't mind paying over $3 a slice but this place just didn't do it for me. I thought the place was also unnecessarily grungy.
There are so many pizza places in NYC and since we were in Williamsburg, we decided to stop by here. I saw a lot of people order take-out so even though there might be a long line, you may have a chance to sit inside to eat. My friend and I came before dinner hours so we were able to enjoy our meals inside the shop. We ordered the regular cheese pizza for $20 which wasn't too bad for how big it was.
Even though it was cheese, I didn't feel like the cheese was too overwhelming. I don't really like too much cheese so I was a bit afraid of the pizza before it came out. However, the pizza was quite good! The pizza was thin-crust with the right amount of sauce on it. It wasn't too soggy and impossible to hold with my hands. I kind of wished we tried different toppings on it but overall, I was still satisfied in the end. Between two people, we had leftovers and took some to-go.
One of my favorite take out pizza places!! You NEED to try the grandma pizza here. It is out of this world. I don't know how they manage to make their pizza dough so fluffy..almost like focaccia. I will occasionally add pepperoni to it as well if I'm in a carnivorous mood.