Tony’s Pizza
“So check out Tony's first then Fortunato's then Roberta's if you are new in the neighborhood.”
“Forget every pizza joint you ever knew; Tony's is where it's at.”
“I also like the aesthetics – i.e. Pepsi machine from the '70s – but the whole place also appears to be as clean as new.”
Tony’s Pizza
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
PokéStop Nearby: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
5 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
This is a good neighborhood pizzeria that looks like its a throwback to when the area was Italian (like Circo Pastry Shop down the block). Nice setup and storefront, busy enough, mostly Italian behind the counter. A bad thing I saw was that behind the counter they had a good 10 pizzas ready for slice reheats. While this is efficient, the slice I tasted definitely suffered because of this. Maybe the sicilian is the thing to get here, as the only pie I saw was on the counter.
The slice had a decent crust which could've been crisper, especially on a reheat. There was a too much cheese, but the sauce was very good. Overall it wasn't quite solid, but it was good for $2 and definitely a pizzeria I'd love to have in my neighborhood. Stop by if you're in the area and don't want to deal with any bullshit over at Roberta's.
Probably goes without saying Tony's blows Pizza de Napoli out of the water.
I'm a NY pizza noob and I stumbled upon this place after finding out they closed down Frankies. So I can't get a delicious inexpensive Brooklyn breakfast, guess I'll get a slice or two instead!
Tony's was moderately busy at 11am, but I was in and out in like 3 minutes. Next time, I'm going to try a pepperoni slice and maybe a sicilian slice since people on yelp are going nuts about it.
This is probably my favorite pizza joint in NY so far! I've hit about 5-6 others including Lombardis. The crust here is crisp, thin, but still has a nice texture and chew to it. They don't skim on sauce like other places but it's not oozing, it's just the right amount.
Okay, so the pizza is really quite good. Fresh and delicious, and only $2. Definitely the best in the area. Sprinkle a little parmesan on there, and you'll be carried away by little pizza angels with golden harps.
I have frequently burned the top of my mouth by not bothering to let the darn thing cool off before devouring it whole.
The only thing that prevents this from being a five-star spot is the scene. Tripping over small unattended young children, and the dodging crazy locals yelling cat-calls at you while you're patiently waiting to get served. There is rarely seating inside. The whole restaurant is kind of a zoo. Still, it is worth it to just stand outside the place with this epic slice.
I had one slice and it filled me up, when I normally eat 2 or even 3 slices. It's actually really good, compared to other pizza places I've had lately, especially in Bushwick.
When you walk in, you basically have to just find someone making eye contact with you and tell them your order. Lines don't exist here.
What
A plain
Slice should be.
Cheesy, good sauce
For two bucks that is simple and made right.