Toby’s Public House
“I've already tried slices from 7 different pies and I gotta say their Smoked Pancetta ($16) and Tartufata ($18) is a most definite must!”
“A pub, with a wood fired brick pizza oven in the back spinning what was quite possibly one of the best "fancy" pies I've had.”
“Love Love Love Toby's, and if you're in to sports, they've always got the game on you want to see.”
Toby’s Public House
Take-out: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Happy Hour: Yes
Outdoor Seating: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range $11-30
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Cool atmosphere. I have to applaud the waitress. Why on earth they had one server on New Years Eve to cover the door, all the tables, food, and running to the bar for the entire restaurant is beyond me. She also had to bus all the tables. Insanity. We were a walk in table of 5. We waited awhile but were happy to do so. The food was very good. I recommend the prosciutto/asparagus/mozzarella appetizer. Also the Bufalina pizza was delish. If you want a bar atmosphere with great pizza, this place is definitely worth 'checking-in' to.
Came here on a Monday night and it was already crowded by 7pm. It feels more like a fancy craft beer house (lots of wood, tin ceiling, 1930's vibe), but they serve both amazing craft beer as well as some of the best pizza around. We got the sopressata with extra sauce and were blown away. Perfectly cooked crust, crunchy and very flavorful. The cheese was light and not greasy, the sauce was abundant and spiced to perfection. And the meat was very high quality and not overly salty like in many places. Also, if you're feeling guilty about all the beer and pizza, they also have an amazing spinach salad.
To top it all off, server was very fast and friendly, despite having a full restaurant to service.
Note: cash only.
When Toby's first opened I really wanted to not like it there. They made that too difficult and I have come around on them. The place is constantly crowded (but usually not overcrowded) – I have never seen the place empty at any time of day or night (I lived not to far away). I would sometimes wonder if all the people there late on a weeknight had to work the next day :). Sit down have a beer and a little something to pick on you won't be sorry.
Mushroom pizza with truffle oil is one of the best pizzas around! Its a small 6 slice pie. Get other things to share!
Mussels are lacking in flavor and I prefer white wine sauce than red sauce mussels. Meatballs were pretty good.
Key lime pie was delicious too!
Great service, delicious pizza, and a solid selection of brews.
The only downside is that they are cash only.
But I'm still a fan!
Excellent pizza, average side dishes, friendly servers, lovely patio. The Toby's brew is cheap (as advertised) and doesn't taste too bad.
The pizza (Smoked Pancetta) was great. However, the ginger ale I ordered tasted funny and the plates on the table were a little dirty…I had to brush crumbs off before food even came! I also wasn't crazy about the naked women all over the bathroom walls. Aside from that, the staff seemed personable and the service was good & fast. Maybe next time I'll do take out if they have it.
Cash
Only.
Fine beer list
But draw is food.
Crispy Neapolitan pizza. Yum!