Percy’s Pizza
“This is easily the best dollar slice in the city (believe me, I've tried the others, which are invariably shitty).”
“Once again, your go to destination for drunk eats.The slice I tried might have even topped 2 Bros for me..”
“I think the only other plain cheese slice in the city that's better is Joe's. So good!!!”
Percy’s Pizza
Take-out: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Home of the $1 slice and it's good! $2 scores a Sicilian style with crisp, flaky crush. Absolutely delicious. Come here for lunch or am afternoon treat. Slices $1-3. Pies $10+
Floppy, soft, uncrispy pizza.
Heard great reviews about this place, some may even consider is one the best dollar slice in the city.
Definitely not. Pizza was weak, didn't have the NYC crispy "crunchy" thin crust. Sauce was also lacking in flavor.
Cheap $1 slices- if you're hungry and on a tight budget, then this is your place. A pie (8 slices) will run you at $10. Holding up 10 fingers and counting. Hmm..
I bought a few slices here and as the old saying goes, "you get what you pay for." The pizza was lacking in sodium and the whole flavor profile was flat. I didn't taste much of anything really- neither tomato sauce nor cheese. The best part was the thin crust: no dough overflow here.
Like I said, a good and fast place for a cheap bite, but if you have a few more dollars to splurge, you could do better.
A-OK. Out of the dollar pizza places, Percy's is probably one of the tastier ones. Their pizza is super thin though, so you end up having to eat 1-2 more slices. There's also very little seating so don't plan on sticking around.
They're super quick about reheating your pizza – although I guess since the pizza is so thin anyways, it's easy to reheat.
One of the most solid dollar slice options in the neighborhood. And it's even worth a second dollar to get them to throw some meatball on top :). Heck, for 8 bucks they'll even sell you a whole pizza!
They blow through pies pretty fast, at least the cheese ones. Which means you have to wait more often than your average dollar place, but also means you're far more likely to get a piping hot slice!
In terms of dollar slice places, this place is slightly below average. The slice is relatively fresh because of a steady flow of college students and is a nice crispiness. However, it is noticeably smaller than most dollar slice places and they are also stingy on the sauce and cheese. Stick to Two Bros. pizza instead.
Battling this snow storm I stopped by for warmth in this pizza shop. I couldn't help myself but buy that green pepper pizza…it was whispering to my belly. Pizza slices are cheap and good here, 1 topping equates to $2. After finalizing my slice I had to get another, so I got one with olives. Great pizza place if your looking for great tasting slices at a cheap price
This place is really good. I am not a fan of thin crust pizza but if you are, you would like this of this place. It's always pretty packed so I finally got a chance to go. It's rated one of the best $1 slices in NYC. The owner is super nice and very friendly and he heated up my pizza unlike Joe's pizza not far away where I had a horrible experience with. Joe's pizza sucks, come to Percy's
My pizza slice was very thinly covered with pizza and tomato sauce. It wasn't anything special for me like I was hoping for but still good.
I think the inside is pretty nice compared to other super sketch pizza places I have been to. There are 3 tables for 2 people to sit at & they're almost always occupied.