Uncle Paul’s Pizza
“When my girlfriend and I were walking to Grand Central we wanted a quick bite before the long ride back to New Haven.”
“Walked in and a few people were there (including a couple of police officers), but it seemed like a typical late night little pizza joint.”
“If your looking for NY pizza this is the place, great slice selection too!!”
Uncle Paul’s Pizza
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Caters: Yes
Good for Working: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range $11-30
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
For it being so late at night, and not many pizza spots to choose from, we stopped here after adventuring the city. The pies were shiny but not with grease so that's a plus but the size of them and freshness are what threw me off. Maybe only tourists wander around that late at night looking for pizza… I had two slices, one with a bunch of meat on it and another which was buffalo chicken which both were tender and had some nice flavor. Oddly, I prefer older pizza over hot out of the oven due to the melt the cheese to the roof of your mouth like napalm feeling it gives me.
I was really hoping that the pies were bigger like the NY pizza I've seen pictures of! The crust was baked nice and crisp on the bottom but other than that, it didn't really knock my socks off.
Had my first slice of pizza in NYC here today. Nice staff and cute place, but the pizza is not at all memorable. The pizza was rather bland and not what I expected from a NYC pizzeria. Still, it was fine. I just wasn't blown away. I have had better pizza in Atlanta.
This place was recommended to me by some people sitting at the bar. Asked them where the best pizza place was within a 10 block radius and this is what they recommended. The pizza in NY is just better than anywhere else. People try and copy this but you can't so stop trying. Just visit NY and try the pizza first hand and put this on your pizza list. Very good and again friendly service by most places in NY.
Ordered the Prosciutto di Parma and Fresh Mozzarella Cheese Panini. It was a sizable sandwich. Perfect for lunch. The cheese was perfectly melted and worked well with the prosciutto. Would definitely order from this place again for lunch.
Expensive thin crust pizza, but will do the trick on those late nights in midtown. This is the back up if the 99 cent joints a block away are too busy. They have premade slices which are nicely topped and cheesed. I really liked the buffalo chicken. They have dessert, beer and wine as well. If you want to sit down at 3 am, maybe have a beer and a slice….this is probably your best option in midtown.
As soon as you walk in the ambience is better than your average pizza place. It looks like a really cutesy Italian cafe with granite tables and warm lighting. But it has the nice speed of a fast pizza place.
We got two of the specialty pizzas (lasagna and chipotle). Both were above average – nice crispy crust and plenty of cheese. Prices were standard for NY.
Overall good and we'd come here again!
service is so sweeet-great if you're in Midtown East!
We were staying at The Roosevelt Hotel while visiting family in the city. After a long day, we stopped ducked in here to eat. The menus are on iPads (nice touch). My two guys (fiancée and his son) ordered a Margherita pie and I ordered the gnocchi pesto. My man was super happy. He's been craving a NY pie for a long time! He was a happy!! I was happy to have a vegetarian option. I asked them to hold the cheese. After the pizza was delivered the waitress came to ask if I had a dairy intolerance, I said yes. 15 minutes later my dish arrived. I'm assuming they out the cheese in and had to remake it. Either way it was delicious. We ordered the rice balls as an appetizer. The description says it had jalapeño it….ummmm it has zero flavor plus cheese so I didn't eat it. But over all we had a great experience. It was super packed the entire time. From 10:30-11:40pm on a Saturday night.