Leone’s Pizzeria

“the staff is friendly, all their delivery guys are great, my food arrives real fast and the lasagna is one of my comfort foods.”

“the soups are tasty, the portions huge, the lasagna cheesy, and they even have rice dishes, veggies and other such goodies.”

Leone’s Pizzeria

Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Outdoor Seating: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Caters: Yes

Price range.

$$ Price range $11-30

3 reviews

  1. If the review were to take place in 2003 before transplanting myself in the deep south for a six year stint, there would be a different story line. The food back then was four to five star in quality, the pizza was excellent and my favorite dish, which was a total knock out was the shrimp parmigiana. Bar none, one of the best I have ever had.

    Fast forward to the current year and date…What the heck happened?
    The shrimp parmigiana was nothing like I had experienced prior. Served in the small rectangle tin, as opposed to the circular and larger tin, the contents were indescribable. The sauce must have been on its last legs, in actuality I think the legs were already out from under the sauce.
    The pasta was gummy and the shrimp were frozen too long and thawed out too quick, resulting in a broken down pink mush.

    I was already conjuring up the contents of my one star review, but thought it wise to give a call to express my great displeasure with the food. The manager offered me a full credit, sight unseen as I offered to drive it back to Leone's while really wanting to bury it in St. John's Cemetery across the street. The Tomb of the Unknown Takeout Dinner.

    The credit was affixed to the cork board and when it was to be redeemed for an eggplant parmigiana and Manicotti, there were no questions, just a kind exchange and a pleasant transaction. I was expecting "who did you speak to?" "Sorry, I was not working that day…yadda ..yadda."

    However the food is just not the same as I remember, even on the redo. But much credit needs to be given for such a easy return and a staff that totally did the right thing when faced with an unhappy customer.. Bravo!!

  2. I was impressed with their chicken cutlet parm and the fried calamari was good too. I'm not crazy about their pizza sauce. It's a little too sweet for my liking but it's a good place to grab a slice.

  3. I wish that I didn't LOVE their pizza and especially their pizza sauce SO MUCH, because something is wrong with my order every single time we order. If you request anything additional, you will not get it. I ask for a side of extra sauce every single time I order and they always say ok. And even confirm it, and it's never there.
    But that sauce….it's sweet and so good!!!

Rate and write a review

Cooper Avenue 8402
11385 NY US
Get directions