Tony’s Pizza, Pasta & Gyro
Tony’s Pizza, Pasta & Gyro
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Caters: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
1 review
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
A friend that lives in the apartment complex above Tony's ordered us a pizza from there many years ago. It was…no. We were all disappointed by how unpalatable a simple cheese pizza could be.
Flash forward to July 2015, as a (now) 11-month long resident of Inwood. I'm a Grandpa's Girl, through and through, patronizing them even when I didn't live in that neighborhood, willing to travel up to Broadway and Isham to pay a bit more for their fine pizza. However, on evening, the beau came to my apartment with a slice of Sicilian from Tony's. I took a bite, with hesitation, and…it wasn't too bad! Had I too harshly judged this establishment all of those years back?
Well, we decided to order a couple of slices from them the other night, as well as some garlic knots. We returned to my apartment, ready to fill our bellies.
…no.
*sigh*
I want to be kind to my little neighborhood pizza place, because I'm too wicked nice, but the pizza and garlic knots were both pretty dry and flavorless. The knots, in fact, did not taste like garlic at all, rather just slightly burned with a buttery note. The cheese ont he pizza did not yield well to our teeth, a little tough, indeed.
Sorry. Like I said, I'm a Grandpa's Girl.