16 Handles

“It does get crowded at times with younger kids and families but hey, you're on UWS in a dessert place with limited seating space so that's just normal.”

“I highly recommend the Graham Cracker flavor- I swear it tastes like pure Graham Crackers in Fro-Yo form!!”

“I might have to open up a franchise in my neck of the woods, but I'd probably gain way too much weight.”

16 Handles

Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
PokéStop Nearby: Yes

Price range.

$ Price range Inexpensive

8 reviews

  1. I love this place and everyone has a least 4 flavors I love, I went a little crazy here with the toopings and wound out with a 11 dollar bill.

  2. I'm completely picky when it comes to frozen yogurt.  I don't like when it's too watery, too many calories, too much of a flavor like Dannon yogurt and boring flavors.   This establishment has everything I want in a yogurt place!!

    They have the best and most flavorful options.  If you're uncertain, ask for a sample.  You can sample any and all!  My favorites are the graham cracker and the peanut butter.  The topping options are endless.  I like the rainbow cookies, peanut butter cup pieces and toffee pieces.

    Be carful because the cups are deceiving and your yogurt cost adds up quick.

    Absolutely my favorite yogurt shop!

  3. After moving to the West Side, I've become a regular here! I'm a fan of the self serve and the choice of flavors. Some taste like soft serve ice cream and the others have more of a tangy yogurt taste. One of my friends is vegan so it's nice that they have dairy free options. The place can get crowded but it's not overwhelming. Also love that they are open super late.

    Definitely get the reward card if you're planning to become a regular like me!

  4. This yogurt place is a few blocks frm my apartment and pacifies my sweet tooth cravings guiltfree.. if u exclude the calories frm d toppings.. Nice collection if flavors. They switch some around every week. And they have smoothies and shakes. Hours are convenient. Staff pleasant. They do deliver as well. The best deal I ran into was 10 ISD for 2 large pre-filled quarts. Recommend- brownie fudge yogurt!! YUMMMM

  5. FLAVORS: pumpkin, salted caramel, coconut, vanilla Tahiti, chocolate, and more. The usual toppings like gummy bears, kiwi, mango, strawberry, blueberries, chocolate chips, etc. I got the coconut, chocolate, and vanilla with some fruit toppings. Mango to go with coconut. Strawberry to go with chocolate. And kiwi to go with vanilla.

    They let you do samples, but the guy has to get it for you. Glad he wears gloves.

    SEATING: good amount of seating and more in the left back area with a TV, which was great because the football game was on. Poster says they do birthday science parties which amazes me because I don't see much space.
    Bathrooms is one toilet room. Outside chairs too.

    PAY: by weight. One cashier is for cash and the other is for debit or credit.

    OVERALL: Standard yogurt place, but well done.

  6. Exactly what you want from a frozen yogurt place. Inventive flavours (which actually taste good – graham cracker was amazing!) and a good selection of toppings (more than Pinkberry) but not so many that they felt stale/unnecessary. I was also pleasantly surprised with my $8 price. Will be back!

  7. Okay, it's a FroYo shop, & those are a dime a dozen here in NYC.

    This particular location is a bit cramped, but on a nice day it's great to sit outside and enjoy.  This location is always fully stocked with a great variety of flavors and toppings, & I always consider buying a pint or an entire birthday cake while I'm here.  Somebody I know has to have a birthday, right…?

    What I love about 16 Handles, though, is their rewards program.  The cup price is what you make of it, but they are CONSTANTLY offering promotions, discounts, and even freebies.  They have what's called the "We Missed You" freebie, which is given if you haven't been to the place in quite some time.  So awesome, and it makes me only want to come to this place.

    Thanks, 16 Handles!

  8. I am a huge of 16 Handles ever since they started popping up in NYC. This location has many flavors, is always up to date has some outside seating, has space to sit inside. The staff is helpful and the flavors are plentiful! Ohhhh 16 Handles how I wish I could quit you!

    Seriously awesome location! Also sign up for their email/card they reward with points to use on your birthday and randomly will add points. I feel from all the NYC frozen yogurt places this is the best chain. Price + Value. I'm a BOB (baller on a budget) and this place fits that budget criteria.

Rate and write a review

Amsterdam Avenue 325
New York 10023 NY US
Get directions
Monday, 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Tuesday, 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Wednesday, 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Thursday, 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Friday, 11:00 am - 12:00 am
Saturday, 11:00 am - 12:00 am
Sunday, 11:00 am - 11:00 pm