44th Street Pizza

44th Street Pizza

Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes

Price range.

$ Price range Under $10

7 reviews

  1. dolla pizza, nuff said. It's quick and it does the job.

    I prefer 2 bros just out of habit, but the guy here's pretty nice.

  2. Utter crap. Low quality pizza. It's essentially a nauseating Domino's knock off.

    For those who choose to patronize this slop fest, think twice; you can walk 6-8 blocks south and get the real deal at Royal, Librettos, or Brick Oven 33. Why choose this garbage?

  3. You only have $2 in your wallet and are hungry for some lunch? Good luck with that in Midtown, or even Manhattan alone, but thank lord almighty that there is something in this world called 99 cent pizza. Granted, it's not the best pizza in the world, but for a buck, you have no right to complain.

    These 99 cent pizza shops are all around the city and they work the same way. Stand it line, hold up your cash money or fingers up to show how many slices you want, grab your pizza, and be on your way. Now this place actually doesn't taste as good as the 99 Cent Fresh Pizza that's around the area, but that's being pretty picky. If you've already decided in your mind that you're going to spend $2 on lunch, then in my opinion, you've given up all rights to complain about quality.

    The lines here always move fast as hell. Even if the line is 20 people long, you'll be in and out within 5 minutes. Snack on your slices on right on the corner, and then be on your way. Us New Yorkers are literally on the go, so don't let something like lunch get in your way. Throw down that $2, get those slices, and be on your merry way.

  4. Crowded so thought it would be pretty good.  Pretty bad quality though.  Wouldn't return.

  5. Stopped in to this new 99 cent pizza spot.  These types of businesses seem to be popping up all over NYC these days.  I guess they are a warm welcome to a city known to be expensive even for lunch.

    The store front is small but neat and clean.  They sell hot dogs & pizza but I think most patrons walk in for the pizza.  This place is almost a true 99cent pizza joint because for two slices I was charge $2 (I guess they charge 1 cent tax; not too shabby).

    Now down to the goods, the actual pizza.  I'm just down the block so when I got to my office the pizza was cold (not ice cold but not very warm either).  They have a dominoes pizza style oven where the pie goes in one end and comes out the other which is probably why the pizza does not come out blistering hot.  Pizza tastes just ok but I think if they could serve hot pizza and I could actually eat it hot when I get to the office it may have brought out the taste better.

    I'm a frequent pizza eater, I just love the stuff but I'm not sure I'll be going back here.

  6. One day for lunch I decided to try this $1 pizza spot. Small pizza store, no seating, you order your pizza, drop your dollar, put some seasoning on your slice and you're out. The slice, decent size, love the sauce, thin crust, I like it a lot. I will be back. One slice is not enough, you'll need 2+.

  7. I've walked past this place a few times without going inside, which should shock a few people because, well, I love cheap stuff, especially cheap foooood! However after seeing what this place has to offer from the outside of it, I decided to stay away from it until this past weekend.

    What is it they sell that I was trying not to consume? 99ct Pizza of course. I know it when I see it, and from the sight of it I know exactly what it will taste like, and I'm not a huge fan of their pizza anymore. I mean, really…it's not very good. I had a slice from here last weekend, and it tasted just as I thought it would…the dictionary definition of the word "Meh".

    I will give this place 3 stars because they also have hotdogs. I didn't have their hotdogs but how bad could it be really? Not to mention, they have a wide variety of toppings as well, which is nice. I mean, not even the great 2 Bros. has sausage as an option and this place does. I also didn't try this either, but I guess if I'm in the area again (which I will be for the next 2 weekends, shooting the new Sam Worthington film Man on a Ledge) I can stop in and try it out….

Rate and write a review

East 44th Street 196
New York 10017 NY US
Get directions