Casa Calamari

“My favorite is the grandma pizza, the buffalo chicken, extra cheese and the good ol' pepperoni.”

“My favorite is the calamari, the wine, the baked ziti and the atmosphere.”

“I haven't had the pizza here, but the eggplant rollatini is killer.”

Casa Calamari

Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Outdoor Seating: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Caters: Yes

Price range.

$$ Price range $11-30

8 reviews

  1. Came here and got pasta and lasagna. Lasagne was good but pasta was a little bit lacking of flavor. Service was very good.

    Came here again because it's really great to sit outside and watch as people walk etc and their pizza is excellent. Greek salad good but small. Soup was also good.

    Chicken parm a little rubbery. Tell them to cook it well if you want to order it. Service always good.

  2. Casa Calamari is indeed one of my favorite Italian spots in Bay Ridge. I have been coming here for a long time. Ive probably tried almost everything here from the pastas, heroes, pizza, salad ect and I have never been disppointed. The service is good and friendly. The only con about this place is that after the fire and  the renovations that they had the prices went up and its pretty pricey here. I don't mind paying for good food but there are many other Italian spots in Bay Ridge which are just as good. I still recommend!

  3. I must put Casa Calamari as one of the gems of Bay Ridge. If you want some good Italian food then you come here in Bay Ridge.

    I came for dinner one night.
    I had the oysters for an appetizer. I must say it was surprisingly delicious. I did not expect the oysters to be sweet. It was really good.
    For my entree dish, I had the Pork Osso bucco with linguini pasta. The pork came right off the bone and it was very juicy. The linguini pasta was probably the freshest and best linguini pasta I have tasted.

    It's a small pizzeria/restaurant, but you will get some top notch Italian food here.

  4. Feels weird to give 5 stars, but here I am! Only eaten in once, and taken out once, but both experiences were great and all my friends say the same thing. Calamari both fried and not, was good, eggplant parm was soft and gooey, eggplant rollatini were good and not too heavy, and the cold antipasti appetizer was still good after a 30 minute trip home.

    Plus, in the summer, the windows/doors are open and it is great dining like that.

  5. By the slice, some of the best pizza you will find ANYWHERE in Brooklyn.
    There are 3 places I get amazing slices in Bay Ridge, and this is always in the running for the best.  Cool little atmosphere, and quaint bar too.  Most warm weather days, the windows are open, on this somewhat busy corner. Nice family oriented place.

  6. YOU HAVE TO GET THE GRANDMA PIE! It is to die for. I also love their penne vodka dish. I have tried other items on the menu that were okay but those two dishes are exceptional. One of the best pies in Brooklyn.

  7. Omg. Leo's crew catered my party at Bench. The meatballs were on point which u can't say about many places. Leo even joined us!  The buffalo wings were spicy n just right. The baked ziti- yum. I'm drunk so forgive me. Omg this food rocks.

  8. I recently moved to Bay Ridge from Sheepshead Bay and I can say that I am thankful for Casa Calamari.  The food is pretty good for what it is – Italian American "fast food" and very reasonably priced. Salute.

Rate and write a review