City Slice
“A tiny little place that is a little neighborhood gem on 10th Avenue.”
“There are a few $1 pizza joints in the blocks surrounding it, but make no mistake, this is no dollar slice (in quality…”
“They have such a nice variety of speciality slices and were so quick to deliver during a Sunday night dinner time rush.”
City Slice
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Caters: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
5 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
They have amazing deals! I ordered the Sixty Nine party deal for $69.99 (2x 18' cheese pizzas, 1x 18' pepperoni pizza, 28 wings, and 3x 2L soda). And they best thing was, when I went pick up my order, they gave me an extra pepperoni pizza!
The pizza was ok, wings were good.
Very satisfied with the delivery. Right on time. Definitely will order again!
I ordered a large 18" Italian supreme (various meats + mushroom + onions) and thought it was a solid pizza. It was a bit too thin for my taste, but it seemed like my friends enjoyed the that texture. Also, the mix of flavors weren't as flavorful as I expected it to be, so I would probably have opted for another series of toppings if I could order again. Nonetheless, the pizza was good value for the price, and delivery was fast!
Walked by this place a gagillion times….really intrigued by all the high reviews……..so…yay!
REAL TIME LUNCH REVIEW!!
Ordered up meatball parm w/spaghetti for now……buffalo chicken & meat lovers slices for later (cuz it be Thick Boy Thursday, y'all!).
Ordered at 3:50pm. They confirmed within two minutes. Arrived by 4:30pm.
Good size slices. Still hot and crispy on delivery. Though meat lovers hardly had any meat on it, and the sauce was sweet. Buff chick was good, though.
That parm looked amazing! Huge, heavy portion. Solid meatballs. Same sweet sauce, though….pasta cooked well (just over al dente). Came with a complimentary warm roll.
If I was into sweet sauce? 3.5. Since I'm not, but they still do a decent slice and pasta? Solid 3.
Although it looks like a bodega/hole in the wall pizza place from the outside, the quality of the food is way better and nothing like the $1 slice joints. I like thin crust pizza, so I am a fan of City Slice when I am craving a good slice of American-style pizza (if you're looking for something more "artisanal," walk to Merilu on 9th avenue).
Somehow, City Slice's pizza crust always stays deliciously crispy throughout the meal, and makes great leftovers without becoming soggy. The quality is also consistent, as I've ordered several times, both pick up and delivery. One time they forgot a topping on my pizza, and they re-made the entire pie and threw in some free garlic knots with plenty of apologies – great customer service! Delivery also arrives in a timely manner.
The quality of their ingredients is what I appreciate the most – when I order vegetarian pizzas, I can taste that the spinach weren't pre-frozen stuff and the mushrooms aren't pre-canned. Fresh ingredients on pizzas are the best! The marinara sauce is also not overly salty, so I never get my typical "post pizza bloat & thirst" when I order from here.
If you live out on the far west like I do, I highly recommend City Slice for your go-to American pizza joint!
Nice place to stop by for a slice of pizza. The crust is nice and crispy and the cheese was of good quality. Service was friendly the place is nice and clean. A tiny little place that is a little neighborhood gem on 10th Avenue.