Coney’s Cones
“I was in the mood for sweet and tart so I went with Milano cookie and mango.”
“I know the two flavors do not really mix well, but both were absolutely delicious and very refreshing on a hot day!”
“When ordering, go to the left, put in your order , pay and then you move to the right and the staff scoops up what you have ordered.”
Coney’s Cones
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
PokéStop Nearby: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range Moderate
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Gelato, sorbet. No need to choose at Coney's cones. Choose your size, pay then choose your favors. Feel free to ask for samples, they're very courteous at Coney's cones.
There are lots of unique favors. From Milano cookie to Dolce de Leche. I was in the mood for sweet and tart so I went with Milano cookie and mango. I enjoyed them both very much. My mom had the strawberry and she loved hers too.
Coney's cones you've gained a fan.
Amazing ice cream! Love this place.. wanted to try the creamsicle soft serve but they didn't have any… will have to go back to try that!
I didn't have high expectations and thought it was your typical dessert shop but I was wrong. It was AMAZING! How could ice cream/gelato taste so good?! The texture was perfect and flavors were on point. I ordered 2 scoops – Mango and Pistachio. If I had to choose my favorite flavor out of the two, it would be a tie.
If heaven made ice cream, this how it would taste like. The customer service was great. I can't wait to return!
Luna Park is like a carnival by the Broad Walk. I love coming out to Coney Island because it reminds me of that old New York City charm. Not modern or hipsterish, just a raggedy carnival without the bells and whistles.
As soon as you exit Luna Park you'll find Coney Cones right on the board walk. There might be a kind but they are quick. I'm not a huge fan of gelato because it melts too fast but I had to give it a try.
It's only 90 degrees outside and NYC is humid as hell, got to get something to cool you down right? Well I had the double scoop pistachio and some other flavor I forgot lol but it was really good. Only thing if melted fast. At least with ice cream the consistency allows you to eat slit toe but before it darts melting but not gelato. It's melting from the second it comes in your hand.
Gelato was good but I rather have ice cream. They also serve good slushy drinks and they are really good! Not your genetic 7/11 type slushy but some real good ish.
Prices are fair as well. I was expecting to pay outrageous prices because that's what everyone popular does these days but not the case here. Anyways if your in the area, go give it a try and I hope you like it!
Best gelato place in the area. The pistachio and cappuccino were very rich, creamy and affordable at 2 scoops for around $5.
Things around Coney Island are expensive, let's face it. Coney's Cones is certainly not an exception, but the quality of their ice cream and gelato was more than I was expecting it to be, and I strive not to have such high expectations. I went with two scoops of Strawberry Cheesecake and a mix of Vanilla and something else (I think) and it was sure delicious. Two scoops for $5.00 around someplace like Coney Island isn't bad at all.
Creamy, large scoops are placed on your choice of cone.
We opted for the basics, vanilla and coffee.
Both flavors were far from disappointment. Creamy and not too sweet. Would I say they're the best scoops of ice cream I've ever had? No. But they were pretty damn good.
Definitely a try-it-once kind of place!
When it's disgustingly hot and sweaty, and you are unable to keep grimy, oblivious and/or obese folk from rubbing their semi-naked bodies against you as you wander down the boardwalk, gelato will help.
Rich, creamy, perfect gelato.
It may cost too much, and somehow the shop is hotter than being in the sun outside, but this is the sort of gelato that can keep you from getting stabby.