Goodfellas
“Really good pizza, and you don't have to hike all the way to Staten Island to get it (though I've never actually had pizza in Staten Island).”
“Words that came out of my mouth while eating the Smokin' Goodfellas Pizza:
"Wow"
"OMG"
"I've never eaten pizza this delicious!"”
“We had The Goodfella which consists of fresh mozzarella, brick oven roasted peppers, sausage & fresh sliced garlic.”
Goodfellas
Takes Reservations: Yes
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Caters: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range $11-30
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
I got the meatball sub and the homemade chips, my boyfriend got a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was New York style with a golden brown crust. He ate 3/4 and took the rest home. He enjoyed it.
My sub was delicious, with fresh, well sized meatballs and a tasty marinara. Although the chips were made there–and lord knows I was drooling for them–they were only okay. The chips are supposed to have rosemary on them, but you couldn't really tell. Next time I'll get the waffle fries instead.
The place was clean and the waiter was young, friendly and attentive. It's worth going back, just don't get too excited about the chips.
Inexpensive Italian food!! I ordered here 3 times for their lunch special, each pasta comes with a Caesar or house salad and some bread. The pasta and salad comes in a huge portion. I could barely finish it. I have tried their Goodfellas chicken and cream, Rigatoni alla Vodka Lunch, and Angel hair with Chicken and Peppers. All the pasta were good.
Stopped while bar surfing with a few friends. Wasn't bad but also not the best. Ingredients did seem super fresh, but pizza was a little limp. Garlic bread with cheese is a go to.
Our server was exceptional although I didn't catch his name
Lapin and I came here the other night for dinner. We got the Buffalo Chicken pizza ($14), meatballs ($5 for 3), cheese calzone ($10) and a couple of sodas ($3 each). Our waiter, Mike was the only waiter but he was very nice and attentive. The pizza was good, but didn't have bruschetta like the one in Staten Island. This pizza is also smaller, think along the lines of a medium size Domino's pizza. Two people can share one pizza but it would leave each person satiated but still peckish. The cheese calzone (mozz and ricotta) was very generous portion and it tasted on par with other pizza places. The meatballs were just okay. They were decently sized but Lapin said they tasted like meatballs you can get at Costco. All in all, we had a great server and the food was good. On a side note, look at the black chalkboard when you sit down because they have specials Sunday – Thursday. On Sundays, you get free cannolis, Wednesdays its free draft beer with a pizza purchase and on Thursday its half price house wine bottles.
Small restaurant in the heart of LES.
Known for it's pizzas and maybe we should have stayed on that course.
We tried some other food from the menu and have to say that it was just not worth it. Even the waiter said at first that maybe you should try the pizza.
Wines were good and the right temperature and reasonably priced.
We'll be back but for the pizza.
Yum, we wandered in her looking for an easy lunch. The pie was nice and light, the mozz was rich and thick. The house salad was actually even very fresh and bigger than I thought. Would come back for sure.
Came here for a company lunch before heading to a team-building activity. Nothing really jumped out at me as being spectacular. Everything was fine. The service? Fine. The food? Fine. The pricing? Fine.
We pretty much all got personal pizzas. No one had any complaints. If I am in the area again, I would probably come back. I'd want to check Yelp first, as they allegedly know just the place.
Great service, yummy food and a nice ambiance. I went with my roommate on a roomie date night and we loved our experience there!!! I will definitely be returning, not only was it great, but it's downstairs….