Insomnia Cookies
“Got a half-dozen (chocolate chip, white chocolate macadamia, M&M, mint chocolate chip etc.) which were all tasty!”
“My favorites are the milk chocolate chunk, macadamia, m&m, or if I'm feelin' like getting chocolate wasted– double chocolate chunk.”
“This place is great for late night snacks when everything else is closed or if you just don't want to go through the hassle of baking cookies.”
Insomnia Cookies
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Inexpensive
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Literally feeling insomnia at like 2 am so I wandered down 34th St all the way from the West Side to get these cookies.
The people working here are really sweet, the lady hooked me up with a couple of extra cookies! Oh heyyy. Hahaha. That made me really happy. I took the entire box over to a local bar and picked at them randomly with an espresso stout. Perfect desert and night cap
I came here for dessert cookies with two friends. Small location. I had a warm double chocolate peanut butter cookie. The first two bites were good and then I realized it was way way too sweet. The peanut butter pieces were just too much sweetness and not enough peanut butter flavor.
There are very few times that I'll go crazy for sweetness. I consider myself a savory girl. However, anytime I'm in the city I have to run into an Insomnia before I begin my journey back to LI. Yea I'm being dramatic but these cookies though (insert heart eye emoji) yummmmm.
I believe there's at least 10 Insomnia Cookies scattered around Manhattan. Who can come between a person and their warm cookies and milk???
The concept of late night cookies with delivery options are dope. I think they deliver to you up to about 3am. I never came and was disappointed. Yummy chocolately ooey gooey goodness that just melts in your mouth.
Don't go too crazy though–diabetic shock might ensue. But I do like to spoil myself then drink about a half gallon of water after to make me feel better about all the calories and sugar I just consumed.
Hey, live a little. Get a couple of warm cookies at 2am if you get that craving. That white chocolate macadamia is everythingggg
I like the concept – late night cookies delivered with milk right to your doorstep.
The cookies are actually pretty good here – I love their snickerdoodle and white chocolate chip macadamia cookies. They're served warm, gooey and soft here.
Solid choice for late night cookies. I've been a long time fan of Insomnia, and they came to the rescue when we were craving cookies at 1 AM. Their delivery boy is really friendly, even though we didn't order for delivery. We met him outside the shop, and he brightly greeted us "Hello! How are you?!" When we entered the shop to order, the cashier said, "he always does that".
I really wanted to love this as the concept is so delicious but it just fell short. I ordered the 6pck with choc chunck and the choc chip but they were not that different from store bought and home baked. $10.60 for 6 cookies… *shrugs* (9.26.15;9p)
Pretty good cookies, bought a box to give out at work, little pricey (12 for $19). I liked that they warmed it up, the chips were all melted and gooey but not raw& half-cooked like Levains
White Chocolate Macadamia – very unbalanced, way too much white chocolate, overbearingly sweet, and not enough nuts
Dark Chocolate Chunk – Best cookie I had. Rich chocolate chunks and chocolate flavor from the cookie, not too sweet
Snicker doodle – Didn't get to try it but my coworkers said it was delicious
Recommended: Dark Chocolate Chip Chunk
Came here with my boyfriend for a quick dessert. The cookies were nice and warm. We both got the double chocolate mint cookie which was delicious. The location is small but comfy.