Insomnia Cookies
“I waited until just before I moved from New York to try their cookies, and am still dreaming of their peanut butter cookies”
“We got the chocolate chunk and the peanut butter cup deluxe cookies….perfect for a nice day in the park!”
“Smaller cookies include snickerdoodle, chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin and peanut butter.”
Insomnia Cookies
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Inexpensive
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
In my opinion the best one was the peanut butter chocolate chip deluxe cookie. A close second was another one of the larger cookies, the chocolate chunk.
Smaller cookies include snickerdoodle, chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin and peanut butter. I just like peanut butter cookies and this one was no exception.
These are warm, melt-in your mouth cookies that will make you feel guilty no matter what. You will also want another one. Probably even after eating six.
It's a small shop, with a little bit of attitude and a smile if you act friendly first. The milk is cold and I noticed the youngsters, probably veterans of insomnia cookies, bring in a carton from the bodega. Milk n cookies.
I saw a group of friends, after eating their first cookies throw their heads back in happiness, clench their fists as if to say, "score!" I know exactly how they feel.
If I lived in the city, I'd be broke, fat and addicted to these cookies. No, they're not cheap. But they're warm, gooey and delicious! Plus they deliver?! I'm coming back in the summer for an ice cream cookie sandwich.
I have to thank this place for their over insensitive, rude service. How can they talk to customers in such a disgusting way?
Okay, this shop is small just like any other insomnia cookies. There's not much room to stand inside and their cookies on display are only by the counter. This is our first time coming here. How do you expect us to know exactly what we want from a mile away, when there was a group of people just in front of us, blocking the cookies?
The girl gave us less than 10 seconds to decide and told us to step aside (with no room there). It wasn't even asked or spoken in a nice manner.
She could have easily said, "excuse me, can you please step aside so the lady behind you can order?" (In which, she didn't know what the heck she wanted either. So, she also had to stand and look. Same amount of time as us. Good job.)
But no, she practically yelled at us to step aside.
Nonetheless, their cookies are still good, hence the 2 stars. If this review was just based on customer service, they'd get negatives from me. There are other insomnia cookies in the city, I'd visit the others next time. Never coming to this location again, save me the trouble.
Legend has it that this place was started by a University of Pennsylvania freshman who baked cookies for drunk and stoned students on campus, then delivered them to dorms. He then "scaled up" into a full-fledged business, and now it's a regional chain.
I'm a straight arrow, so you know that if I appreciate this cookies, they're really that good. You definitely should try and eat them right when you get them out since they're warm and a tad moist. Prepare to hate yourself for a bit afterwards because the smallest portion is a "6 pack," and that won't describe your abs when you're done. Ugh.
Small place. The cookies were decently good. Nothing out of this world. I personally think it's overrated. If you're here, give the s'mores cookie a try.
LEGIT. Walk in, hand the man your $1.60, and get handed a warm gooey cookie. What else is there to say? I tried the chocolate chunk and WOW — perfect, dense amounts of melty chocolate, and soft but not oily cookie. As much as I wanted to write it off as a trendy ripoff, I am a Believer. Insommmmmmmniaaaa, I will be back.
Nom nom nom. I like cookies like this, basically half-cooked and messy.
I had the white chocolate macadamia nut and half a snickerdoodle – couldn't even eat them both, no matter how much I wanted to.
Probably not the best cookie I've had in my life, but for the hours, and the decent price, it's a winner.
Ok, this place is dangerous… Fresh cookies delivered to your door until 3am.Plus they are relatively cheap and taste good enough.
The delivery guy also followed my instructions flawlessly. Called my cell instead of buzzing the bell so as not to wake the kids. (Plus, now we only have to share two cookies!)
My family is in big trouble… Do they have a 12 step cookies anonymous?