Jimmie Steiny’s Pub

(2) (718) 442-9526
Write a review Review

“I had a few kids with me and worried about taking them in – but it was excellent.”

“She gave some great recommendations of local peeps to know So the word on Yelp is they have good burgers here.”

“She basically gave us the best recommendation for buffalo wings and where to go on the rest of our Staten Island adventure.”

Jimmie Steiny’s Pub

Take-out: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Happy Hour: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes

Price range.

$$ Price range $11-30

2 reviews

  1. First and only bar on Staten Island! I was pleasantly surprised.

    Definitely a dive, and cash only. However it is what I consider cheap. My buddy and I were drinking Coors Light pints and they were $3 normal price, $2 for happy hour. The bartender was friendly and made conversation with us. She was about 40 I'd say and seemed to be an "islander."

    The crowd seemed, um, eclectic. Lots of interesting people, I'll put it that way, but everyone seemed nice and we chatted a bit with the gentleman seated next to us.

    We didn't eat but we did see they have food, which is good to know.

    Overall a good experience that rests almost completely on our bartender and the cheap beers. Side note: I struggle a bit with reviewing dive bars because really they're all 1 or 2 stars. However, most of what makes me like a bar is the people, and we had a nice time here. The service was good, the beer was cold and cheap. Four stars and I'd come back if I was in the area.

  2. Came here for a friend's going away party. She really enjoys Karaoke so I believe that's one of the main reasons why this establishment was chosen as well as how close it is to the Staten Island ferry.

    There was an abundant list of songs to choose from. The bar area was narrow but long. For whatever reason I wasn't in a drinking mood that day. I had one drink which was okay. Service was friendly and attentive to our large party.

    I'd definitely recommend this place to people who enjoy singing karaoke in a laid back atmosphere.

Rate and write a review