Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

“However, their famous Buffalo Chicken & Blue Cheese slice is my favorite as it offers a great blend of pizza, spicy wings, and blue cheese.”

“Pizza is perfect, buffalo slice is tender and perfectly toned, pinwheels are to die for…”

“The Details: In a world full of specialty pies, flatbread pizzas, and homemade sauces, Mama T's takes the cake for Buffalo chicken pizza.”

Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Accepts Apple Pay: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Caters: Yes

Price range.

$$ Price range $11-30

8 reviews

  1. Ordered take-out last night and was astounded by the bill.  Their prices have gone up.  $50 for two pasta entrees and a salad to go?  Too much.

  2. My family cannot go more than a week without having our dose of Mama T's. I remember it being a little tiny pizza shop when I was a kid and am excited that it has morphed into this beautiful chain of restaurants. The owner is always friendly. The food is consistent and very fresh. The tomato sauce is to die for. I have never taken a person of any age from any background that did not enjoy eating here. The energy is positive and festive. I recommend this to everyone.

  3. We came here with the specific intent in getting some gluten free pizza. When ordering gf pizza we are usually pretty picky about the quality…  How dry is it due to lack of sauce, how crunchy (not soggy), and taste.

    Mama Theresa's was ok. Nothing exceptional or horribly bad.  I'm gonna take a guess the actual crust is not homemade, as most places usually buy them somewhere wholesale.

    We had ordered two pizzas. The pizza pies on both fell flat on being crunchy. Middle was very chewy.  This could possibly have been fixed with a longer cooking time.

    The margarita pizza had a great taste and sauce. The prosciutto however was not what we had expected. Extremely dry (no sauce at all?? Cmon!), and lacking in taste. Mostly just a cheese pie with no flavor.

    Ordered a salad on the side as well (mozzarella with vinaigrette). It was good, but could have been made better maybe with some peppercinis for extra flavor.

  4. I've been here a few tomes its awesome.

    Fantastic Pie. The Margarita is best.

    Veal Franchisee is so lemony. Killa

  5. Like fine wine, some dining experiences get better. This applies to Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Restaurant. Through the years, the delicious menu improves with time.  

    Some years ago, I remember coming here and tasting amazing food.  The linguini with white clam sauce melts in your mouth!  It tastes marvelous! The clams smells and tastes fresh. The garlic gives it more flavor. The linguini tastes perfect.  I like moments like these where I can enjoy each and every bite.    

    Our server comes quickly to us and was pleasant. He flashes a sweet smile and  makes sure we received enough fresh bread and butter. You get free soda refills with your meal.

    The menu features salads, seafood, various pasta dishes, heros, and meat dishes. Don't forget to look at the wine list! You really can't go wrong with a  menu like this.    

    As with a family atmosphere, this place encourages you to take your time to eat and enjoy your conversations. I see many people bring their relatives here.  

    Why not enjoy wonderful food in a family setting here?    I recommend this place to anyone who loves Italian dishes.

  6. Love the pizza here omg the white slices are amazing. Best pizza on Long Island. We eat here usually once a week. You haven't had amazing pizza until you come here!

  7. The food at mama Theresa's is fabulous
    During lunch time the parking lot is pretty crowded
    Staff is always fast and friendly

    They have section for wait staff and a section if you just want to pick up a few slices and go real quick

    The specialty slices here are pretty good I have to say and have a good variety with vegetables sauce and meat on most items.

    The stuffed meat slice is packed heavily with meat. Be warned haha if that's what you are going for.

  8. Finally was able to get the chance to try their pizza. I had been passing by this pizzeria everyday as my route going home is along Jericho Turnpike.

    Today, i tried their take out service for a whole thin crust pie with broccoli and spinach toppings. Fast and reliable service. Less than 10 minutes waiting time on a weekend. Nice counter staff. Average price for a 16"  pie.  I can't wait to taste it while driving home as it smelled heavenly good. The pie is amazingly good, crust is crunchy, loved how they cooked my veggies…chewy and flavorful. This is the way how I want my pizza be done. I enjoyed each bite especially that it was fresh from the oven.

    Did not have any trouble parking, the pizzeria is  located in a commercial center with plentiful spots for customers cars.  Will definitely come back for their dining option.

Rate and write a review

Jericho Turnpike 2429
Garden City Park 11040 NY US
Get directions
Monday, 10:30 am - 10:00 pm
Tuesday, 10:30 am - 10:00 pm
Wednesday, 10:30 am - 10:00 pm
Thursday, 10:30 am - 10:00 pm
Friday, 10:30 am - 11:00 pm
Saturday, 10:30 am - 11:00 pm
Sunday, 9:30 am - 8:00 pm