Moonshine Modern Supper Club

“I have had the immense pleasure of meeting Victor a couple times, and you know he takes pride in this restaurant.”

“Brunch is a prix fixe two course meal for $20, or $30 for unlimited mimosas, bloody marys, sangria, or their featured beer.”

“I would encourage anyone looking for a venue for a wedding or party to seriously consider Moonshine.”

Moonshine Modern Supper Club

Takes Reservations: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Happy Hour: Yes
Coat Check: Yes
Outdoor Seating: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Caters: Yes

Price range.

$$$ Price range $31-60

8 reviews

  1. After seeing Cinderella at the movie theater and eating a ton of secretly stashed munchies, the Three Witches (my sis-in-law Bianca J., soon-to-be-sis-in-law Tess T., and I) descended upon Moonshine Modern Supper Club this Wednesday around 7pm without a reservation and were seated immediately. We parked behind the restaurant in a free lot accessible from Taylor St… and YES, we can eat, then eat some more.

    I ordered a well-balanced and sufficiently gingery Ginger Sidecar in a glass rimmed with cane sugar. Mmmmm! For my entree, I had the House Made Ricotta Gnocchi sized on the bigger side with savory pulled duck, chestnuts, apples, cauliflower, and currants, in a warm butter-based sauce. Very tasty and fitting for the windy day. Bianca let me try some of her Forest Mushroom Ravioli with white shrimp, arugula, onions, and gorgonzola cream sauce, and it really DID taste like a foresty feast.

    For dessert, I was served a super generous portion of Dark Chocolate Mousse and tried some of Bianca's Key Lime Cheesecake. The very chocolately mousse was great for sharing while the cheesecake could have used a lot more lime, but was otherwise good. I look forward to dining here again, brooms optional, especially as the weather warms up.

  2. Went for Saturday brunch and there were about 4 tables full. Wait service was attentive if a bit formal for the circumstances. It was pricey at $20/ person for a 2-course set price brunch (with no option to skip the appetizer/salad course), plus 1 Diet Coke and tip = $50-60 brunch. But my smoked salmon Benedict was tasty. Mini lemon corn muffins were good too. Not entirely sure what to think, or if I will try it again for dinner. I'm moving to town though, so we'll see!

  3. I've only been here for brunch, so I can't talk about the actual 'supper' part of the restaurant. What a hidden gem! It's located off Millburn Ave in Millburn and honestly, you'd walk right by it if you didn't know it was there. I highly recommend seeking it out, though. It's worth it.

    Brunch is a prix fixe two course meal for $20, or $30 for unlimited mimosas, bloody marys, sangria, or their featured beer. The food is all excellent. I had their duck the first time and their eggs benedict the second time, and both were absolutely delicious. Portions are small, which isn't surprising considering you get two courses of high end food for $20.

    The options aren't very vast, but they do cover pretty much any taste. From salads to breakfast foods to burgers and more.

    I have been twice now and will definitely be back again.

  4. Unfortunately, it's a much better place to grab a drink than it is to have dinner. I suppose the title "supper club" is a bit of a misnomer.
    The list of cocktails, beer and wine is extensive and impressive. The bar area is welcoming and the bartenders are friendly and efficient.
    The menu is wonderful in its appearance. An ambitious array of seafood and meats, with a few steaks tossed into the mix. However, the execution leaves much to be desired. The result just doesn't quite live up to the promise.
    I'd sooner return for drinks and the bar menu than I would to actually have dinner. It's a shame because they really have a nice space. With a few minor tweaks, they could have something special.

  5. Had dinner there last night and thought it was quite good. Started off on kind of a downer note because we were seated at a table between the kitchen and the bathroom. Fortunately, the layout of the restaurant didn't really negatively affect our dining experience and we were fairly well isolated from any commotion.

    We ordered a couple of drinks, salmon and the risotto which were all excellent. The restaurant itself is quite visually striking. Lighting is dim, tables well situated and music was excellent. Also worth mentioning was our server, Bruna. What a doll! She was attentive, efficient and way cool. Will definitely ask for her the next time we stop by. You should, too.

    I am really trying to diversify my dining choices. I've been told that I'm a creature of habit and want to break out of that. Doing so involves delving deeper into towns with solid dining choices like Millburn. My journey began last night with a nice option. I can easily see putting Moonshine into our regular dining rotation. Definitely worth a try, especially if there's still a risotto on the menu…..Mmmmmmmm

  6. We were looking for somewhat quiet place to talk and have a drink, post dinner, and stumbled into Moonshine.  I'd been there a few times for after work cocktails and it was always loud, crowded and not the best place to just chill mid week.  To my surprise, the ambient music was perfect, service was outstanding and Heather (our bartender) made of the best Old Fashions I've ever had.  Bravo zulu to her.

    She took meticulous care to muddle cherries, drain out the pulp as to allow for more bourbon goodness.  Perfectly balanced drink, sweet but not too sweet.  Normally, I'd have an Angel's Envy rye but they were out.  So, instead she recommended Eagle's Rare, a 10 year old bourbon.  WOW!  I think I found a new discovery.

    Unfortunately, I wasn't able to stay more than an hour but you can rest assured that I'll be back.  Perfect mid week place to relax, have a drink and a conversation.  Most places turn up the volume too much.  Fine for Friday nights and weekends but nice to find an upscale bar.  I like the fact that they have a separate dining area too.

  7. I've only been for brunch but thought the food was good and the service was attentive. The basket of muffins they give are a nice touch and very tasty. Brunch is $20 for a two course meal, $30 if you choose to do the endless bubbles. I ordered the 'egg in a hole' which I really enjoyed for my first course, and the rum raisin french toast for my main course, which was very pretty to look at, but just okay. Overall I would go back and would like to try their dinner as well.

  8. A very nice upscale restaurant/bar. They definitely try to maximize the space. I don't mind feeling a bit cramped as long as the drinks are well made, it just makes for better people watching, and it's usually a good lookin' crowd. Only food I had here was the pizza and it was very good.

Rate and write a review

Main Street 55
07041 NJ US
Get directions
Monday, 11:30 am - 1:00 am
Tuesday, 11:30 am - 1:00 am
Wednesday, 11:30 am - 1:00 am
Thursday, 11:30 am - 1:00 am
Friday, 11:30 am - 2:00 am
Saturday, 11:30 am - 2:00 am
Sunday, 11:30 am - 1:00 am