More Steak Than Philly

“I'm delighted to support this local business.”

“1 chicken wings are awesome 2 the curly fries yum yum with the house sauce 3 cheese steak was delicious.”

“This place was such a great find at 1AM on this part of Long Island.”

More Steak Than Philly

Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Caters: Yes

Price range.

$ Price range Under $10

8 reviews

  1. This place was such a great find at 1AM on this part of Long Island. I ordered the fish and fries and it was absolutely delicious! The fish was crispy and seasoned very well. I had about 4 pieces of fish and a huge side of curly fries for about $8. I'm very "saucey" and he provided more than enough ketchup and tartar sauce without even asking.

    Great Price, Good Food, Huge Portions, & Open Late!
    I'll be back!

  2. I've lived in Philly for years and this place is definitely a contender. The food is delicious and the customer service is great. However, the wait time is insane. I've never seen cheesesteaks take so long to make, but the quality and taste make it al worth it.

  3. Great AUTHENTIC cheesesteaks!  

    The owner is a very nice guy, too.

    I'm delighted to support this local business.

  4. I lived nearby in the area most of my life. More Steak Than Philly is a new kid on the block. MSTP offers a wide variety of Philly Steak Sandwiches.  Most popular being the Chicken Philly Steak. Chopped white meat covered in cheese, peppers and onions on a pillow soft hoagie roll. My only complaint here is the dry texture of the chicken. It reminded me of Chicken of The Sea Tuna. Maybe i needed more sauce, maybe more cheese, perhaps the A1 or Buffalo Chicken Steak couldve remedied the issue of texture?                                                

    The steaks are now $8.50. What you receive is a sub filled with meat, onions and cheese. The gentlemen at the counter were friendly and service was Quick, fresh, served piping hot in a hurry. Took about 15 min cook prep time. I watched it be made in front of me. This shop is No Frills and for late night grub after the club or midnight cravings. Plastic chairs and a delicatessen dive feel. Gets the job done. I will be back like Arnold to sample the other unique creations that could make or break the addition of a 4-5 Star increase.

  5. If you once liked Chicken Holiday, More Steak Than Philly is a great alternative only a few blocks away. As other reviewers have said, it's more of a takeout place than a sit down restaurant.

    My friend and I got the wings in "Oriental Chicken" and "Buffalo" (3 pieces of each for around $9). The Buffalo wings were super spicy, and the Oriental Chickens were good if salty. We would probably only get the Oriental Chicken flavor again, but overall good fried food if you're in the mood!

  6. I had purchased a deal on Groupon and gave this place a try.I did not oder their cheesesteak but did order their chicken wings,overall I am definitely a satisfied customer.I will once again visit More Steak Than Philly.The service is very slow ,that is in fact the only drawback.

  7. MORE STEAK THAN PHILLY!

    Just the name of this place alone is pure GENIUS! This place definitely has a divey look to it, so don't be alarmed. I saw four lawn chairs when I entered lol, but that didn't stop me from ordering. I wanted something greasy and filling…I was HUNGRY and was not in the mood for a diner.  

    I ordered the A1 PHILLY CHEESE CHICKEN sandwich. They have the option of steak, but I love that they have the chicken alternative for those who don't eat beef. My sandwich was loaded with chicken, cheese, green peppers and a delicious oriental garlic sauce. I didn't know what to expect when I took the first bite, but let me just tell you…it was the MOST DELICIOUS PHILLY CHEESE that I ever had in my life! The sandwich was seasoned just right and had the perfect amount of cheese.

    This place was so good that I went two nights in a row! This will definitely be my new late night spot, and they close at 2 AM! If you're craving something quick and delicious you must try MORE STEAK THAN PHILLY!

  8. I went to More steak than Philly to get some Philly cheese steak sandwiches.I ordered two double meat cheese steaks. This is essentially a takeout only eatery. These were rather large quite filling sandwiches (about 3/4 of a pound each). The high quality mix of cheese steak and onions was almost perfect. The price of the item was about 10.00 each not bad for such a large sandwich. The price to value ratio here is about average for this type of eatery. This was a very good experience and I look forward to returning in the near future.

Rate and write a review

Grand Avenue 1293
Baldwin 11510 NY US
Get directions
Monday, 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
Wednesday, 4:00 pm - 12:00 am
Thursday, 10:00 am - 2:00 am
Friday, 10:00 am - 2:00 am
Saturday, 10:00 am - 2:00 am
Sunday, 10:00 am - 12:00 am