Pisa Pizza

“the pizza here is greasy but so gooood after a good time at Visana.”

“They even use the same brick oven as the old restaurant.”

“I've always said that 1st ave and 14th to 23rd is prime real estate for food joints that could take StuyTown by storm, and Pisa es here to take on the challenge.”

Pisa Pizza

Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Caters: Yes

Price range.

$ Price range Under $10

6 reviews

  1. It's a little tiny pizza place with a lounge in the back.  Cool concept. They also didn't get too upset at me sitting near the hot pizza oven when I was cold that night.  The pizza itself was pretty good and it was a nice little experience.  I'd return though you might not want to go here for meal times when the place may be packed.

  2. Great pizza by the slice and great staff.

  3. We ordered a 14" pie with onions and mushrooms.  It was at best, average, but less than average considering the $18 price.

    The pizza was very thick and heavy, much like the stuff I grew up on in Pennsylvania and I'm fairly certain the mushrooms came out of a can.  

    Maybe it's better to go here when it turns into more of a bar? Because the pizza would be better when the utility of sopping up alcohol is needed.

  4. I've always said that 1st ave and 14th to 23rd is prime real estate for food joints that could take StuyTown by storm, and Pisa es here to take on the challenge.
    They are open til 4 am which is a game changer for this street and all them people up in the apt tryna eat after screwing around all night.
    The staff was super nice and the inside is pretty modern looking and chill. It definitely looks out of place on 1st ave along with Tal Bagel down the street, but I guess we renovating up this street.
    I got the white slice, which is by far ma fav type of pizza. Can I be super honest doe it was aite! It was not heavy which is a HUGE plus and had crunchy bottom//crust which is solid. But it was a lil too thin on the cheese and sauce content. The taste was pretty spot on but the blanco taste was not consistent throughout the slice. The prices were average but the thinness of the slices speak to the lesser quantity. Since it's a new joint starting out id give them a curve! 3.5 rounded up! But no mistake still pretty bomb!

  5. the back door opens to Visana, so sneaky!
    the pizza here is greasy but so gooood after a good time at Visana. so strategic!! But I mean, you'd deserve it after dancing up a storm all night! Late-night context aside, it really does stand alone as a great, warm, filling classic slice of NY pizza.  If you're not dancing before you consume this, you better put your dancing pants on and get moving after you eat it.

  6. Wee yummy NY pizza!  Everyone always talks about how NY pizza is so good, and up until coming here, I was always like. Meh.  But yay! It's also a plus that it's not too far from where I am throughout most of the day.  I like the place's name too hehe punny.

    The service is GREAT! There was only one person working when I went, but he was so so sweet and funny.  Always a nice thing when your only break in the day can be brightened up like that.  I got a regular cheese slice and a bacon/chicken slice with a cream soda.  This was all under $10 which isn't bad.  The cheese slice was slightly greasy, but both were delicious.  I also really REALLY appreciate that although it was thin on the bottom, it wasn't so thin that it was flopping over and soggy.  

    I shall definitely be back!

Rate and write a review

1st Avenue 321
New York 10003 NY US
Get directions
Monday, 11:00 am - 12:00 am
Tuesday, 11:00 am - 12:00 am
Wednesday, 11:00 am - 3:00 am
Thursday, 11:00 am - 3:00 am
Friday, 11:00 am - 3:00 am
Saturday, 11:00 am - 3:00 am
Sunday, 11:00 am - 12:00 am