Potbelly Sandwich Shop
“The hot peppers gave it some nice heat, and all the other vegetables gave it a nice refreshing crispness.”
“Your wreck was just as delicious as I had remembered…thank goodness it wasn't just nostalgia.”
“Get my usual turkey, cheddar, with mayo, peppers, veggies and Italian seasoning.”
Potbelly Sandwich Shop
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Accepts Apple Pay: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Caters: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Wow wow wow… I got the Italian sandwich and was not disappointed whatsoever.
But can we talk about their baked goods?!! CHOCOLATE CHIP OATMEAL COOKIES. The sugar cookies were still warm.
Can't wait to go back!
I was in the area for a concert at Madison Square Garden and I thought it'd be smart to eat something before the show so I wouldn't end up spending $20 on popcorn inside, lol.
I'm from Miami so I wasn't familiar with Potbelly, their menu, and their food. I decided to just look at the menu and go with the first thing that caught my attention. 5 minutes later I was faced with a Pizza Sandwich on brown bread.. eh, the name is probably the yummiest thing about it, sadly.
So, what's in it? The Pizza Sandwich had meatball, pepperoni, capicola, provolone cheese, marinara sauce, mushrooms, and Italian seasoning. For my sandwich, I ordered it with no mushrooms and I added some hot peppers.
I won't sit here and say the sandwich was horrible, but it lacked a lot of the yum factor that you would expect from a sandwich made at a place KNOWN for sandwiches. I would freaking take a Publix Sub over a Potbelly sandwich any day.
I can't exactly pinpoint what I didn't like about it but it was blah, there should've been MORE MEAT and more marinara sauce, it was mainly bread and a ton of the hot peppers.
I don't like my sandwiches heated, so maybe this spot isn't for me. But it's tasty enough.
I love this place! Being from Florida we don't have any Potbelly's here, I've been to one in DC and loved it so when I saw this while in the city I immediately crossed the street to have a quick bite. The sandwiches are delicious and the service behind the counter is super friendly!
I love potbelly's but this location is not my favorite.
During week days lunch: line out the door, the service is fast, but you still have to wait among a lot of others before getting your delicious sandwich.
During weekend: it seems they leave the "slower" employees working these shifts, and the service is very very slow, and tables are dirty.
Bright side: there's love music during popular hours (lunch time/weekdays)
Came in on a Saturday, and customers were very sparse. I have waited a solid 10 mins for my Oreo milkshake. Not because it was super packed, but because the server prepping my milkshake went at a very leisurely pace, chatting with her fellow coworkers, and just overall taking her time. The milkshake was good, but these servers really need to speed it up with the service.
A decent option for a sandwich, especially in Midtown but definitely not the best sandwiches ever. 2 steps up from subway, I'd say.
I got "a wreck" ( salami, roast beef, turkey & ham with swiss cheese) with mayo, lettuce, and tomato. A little over $6 bucks.
It was filling enough.
I ordered the Mediterranean sandwich on a flatbread. My sandwich was slightly cold on the inside but overall had a good taste. It was very messy because of the hummus and feta cheese. My boyfriend got the pizza sandwich which was delicious and nicely toasted. The service was good too.
The store does not have much variety or unique sandwiches. With a name like Potbelly, I assumed there would be very unusual and different sandwiches.