Shake Shack
“The fries were excellent too…..on the skinnier side, crispy on the outside, soft in the inside, cooked to perfection.”
“Shake Shack definitely has the most tasty burgers around and this location by Battery Park City is no exception.”
“Add to that the great concretes and nice mix of indie rock tunes playing in store and you've got yourself a real winner.”
Shake Shack
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Outdoor Seating: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Dogs Allowed: Yes
PokéStop Nearby: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range $11-30
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
If you don't wait to wait for your burgers and your crinkle cuts, this is the place to come. At least at the dinner hour. The shortest lines you're likely to see at any Shack in town. Decent seating inside, and great outdoor options too, to rival Madison Square's al fresco atmosphere. Or, the ultimate outdoor experience, go eat at one of the many many benches along the river.
Plus, the 11pm hours have the Brookfield Place spots beat by at least 2 hours.
Best of all, you get to watch the young'uns of Tribeca stream in after their little league games … Bats (and dads) in town.
Shack stack was on point. The new cheddar and bacon. Did I say White Cheddar? Oh no, I didn't but just wanted to clarify and say it again. Good stuff and love when the cheese is melted and overflows outside of the burger and bun. So good.
I don't know what it is about the burgers here, but they are so darn good!
Got the shack burger, smoke shack, shroom burger, and chick 'n stack burger. Got the cheese fries and strawberry mint lemonade to go with it.
As always, the burgers are delicious. This was my first time trying the chick'n shack. Crispy chicken cutlet with pickle, lettuce, and herb mayo. Good combination. The batter they use on the chicken is tasty.
The cheese fries are a cheesy indulgence. Good as always. I'm so glad they are using crinkle cut fries. One time when I came, maybe a few years ago, they were using the regular skinny fries. It just wasn't the same.
The strawberry mint lemonade was SUPER sour on first sip, but once I got past that, I did taste the strawberry and mint. However, I thought the mint flavor was very artificial, and it felt like I was drinking liquified sour strawberry toothpaste. Not what I usually go for. I have yet to be impressed by any of the drinks or shakes on their menu.
Coming from California – Shake Shack is supposed to be the equivalent to In N Out on the West Coast, except Shake Shack isn't anything close to great when compared to In N Out.
This is my second time at a Shake Shack, and I will admit, the 'Shroom burger is divine! That fried mushroom, with all the cheese that oozes out is sublime. I also really like the cheese fries, but they are too salty for me – will have to get them without salt next times.
The prices are a little steep, $7 for that 'Shroom burger! Overall, definitely a place to try when in New York, but not comparable to In N Out!
Very underwhelming. I'm from the West Coast, and I can very confidently say In-N-Out's burgers are much better. Shake shack's burgers aren't as fresh, and they're really small! Not enough vegetables, and it was a very, very, very average burger for a high fast-food price at $5.29 per burger pre-tax. I got the coffee milkshake which was very thick and creamy, and it's comparable to In-N-Out's milkshake. The one I got wasn't very sweet which was great, and I enjoyed the milkshake much more than I enjoyed the burger. It was expensive too at $5.29 pre-tax. There's some places to sit and it's pretty clean. Not sure what's up with the hype.
My dearest Shake Shack. It is my top priority to visit you whenever I make it to the city. You are the only "Popular with millennials on Instagram" thing I've ever been dragged to that lived up to the hype. Your mushroom burger is dripping with all the right juices in the best way possible. Your concrete ice creams make a grown man weep. You have a Brooklyn Brewery beer that is exclusive in two ways: You are the only ones that have it and it's exclusively the only good beer Brooklyn Brewery has ever made.
I've been to a couple different Shake Shacks and the quality is consistent. It's my absolute favorite of the trendy or beloved burger joints and blows In n' Out and Five Guys out of the water. Even Smashburger is a distant second. It's also relatively affordable considering how much they could get away with charging.
Overall, one of the highlights of visiting NYC and should be on every tourist's list!
My first shake shack experience and I can say it lives up to its name! Especially enjoyable after an evening of walking around the city. Although In-N-Out is still my favorite by far, shake shack is still very delicious in their own way!
You can't go wrong with a burger on sweet bread.
My favorite is the SmokeShack.
Worth it, every time!