Starlite Restaurant & Pizza
“Since Robert Irvine left, there is a renewed love and passion by this family to deliver pure excellence.”
“The sandwiches continue to be excellent with w double dog up there with Jimmy Buff's. The pasta is just ok.”
“So much so that my friends now come out to NJ every other Friday just to have pizza, pasta, and Karaoke!”
Starlite Restaurant & Pizza
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Caters: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range $11-30
6 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Yum! Second best thin pizza in the Oranges.
This place gets three stars from me only because the pizza is decent. IT IS NOT STAR TAVERN, as badly as they wish they were it ain't happening… Not never.
On another note, There's some guy who answers the phone sometimes who can be a huge jerkoff. Idk what he problem is, I worked at a pizzeria for 7 years and I would never talk to a customer like he has no matter how bad of a mood I was in… The inside of this place has never been updated. I would be content just grabbing a pizza for take out every once in awhile instead of going in and sitting down… Maybe they can get a nicer person to answer the phones? Haha
I suppose everybody has an opinion right? So here is mine…. Its so incredible to see a family reborn through the positive energy infused by Restaurant Impossible. If you love West Orange, then you need to support this staple of our wonderful town. Patty is by far one of the most passionate and hard-working restauranteurs i have ever met. Since Robert Irvine left, there is a renewed love and passion by this family to deliver pure excellence. If your writing a negative review, i challenge you, did you bring that to her or anybodies attention? I am confident that she would make it right.
So on to the food…. First of all, the BEST gluten free pizza in town for those with the sensitivity. We also had the Polpette (meatballs) which were moist and packed with flavor. The fried artichoke heart was golden brown and delicious. My chicken parm, while not a complicated dish, was executed properly.
Recent review noted…. If the temperature is off, tell the owners. If your waiter or waitress is learning, have patience since they are likely new. What is important, as noted by reviews, the pizza is GREAT. and the staff/owners are committed to making sure you enjoy your meal.
Support local businesses and families… so excited for them and will continue to be a regular of Starlite.
I went to this place on karaoke night. It was definitely a place for regulars but the crowd was extremely welcoming. My coworkers and I had a great time. The pizza was tasty but too oily for my taste. The drinks were really good and the people who worked there made you feel like a regular. I was pleased with the customer service. Would definitely come back.
thin crust deliciousness. I've been eating this pizza for fifteen years so I may be a little bias!
We'd heard this place was an institution when we moved into the area so were excited to try it. We picked up a regular cheese pizza. I enjoy a thin crust, but this tasted budget — everything was super greasy and lacked any fresh flavor. The sauce was mediocre and the cheese was too oily. This may have been the place to go back in the day, but it's not worth trying now.