The Nautilus Diner

“This is one of my favorite diners in the new Rochelle/larchmont area.”

“Gotta say, this diner is the closest thing (that's in Westchester) that compares to a NYC diner.”

“This is prob the best diner in the area (from my experience of new rochelle to portchester).”

The Nautilus Diner

Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes

Price range.

$$ Price range $11-30

8 reviews

  1. The Nautilus is one of my favorite diners to go to. It may be a little out of the way for me, but they have an extensive menu and the food is better than other diners I've been to.

    The decor and layout is typical of a diner – light(er) color scheme, a large counter area with seating, and multiple dining rooms with booths and tables. In terms of food, most things I've had are pretty well done. You can't go wrong with breakfast, and their sandwiches and salads are also pretty good.

    Service is okay – I have no complaints about the wait staff, they're attentive and friendly. My only real (arguably selfish) gripe is with those working the front of the house. I've been going to this diner regularly for a number of years, and the same people have been working the front of the house the whole time. I'm sure they recognize me, but not once has any of them greeted or acknowledged me like I was a regular – it's the same cold (or lack of) greeting every time. I'm not looking for special treatment, but I'm one of your regulars – it would be nice to be greeted like one. It's not a deal breaker for me, but it is a turn-off.

    Overall, they serve good diner food which will keep me coming back.

  2. It's a diner.

    With an extended menu so that all of my glutarded and non-meat eating friends can enjoy.  They are open 24 hours so you can always eat.  What more can I say.

    It's a diner.

  3. This is one of my favorite diners in the new Rochelle/larchmont area. Forget getting your wings at bdubs, you got to try the wings here! They're delicious!

    They're open 24 hours a day and have a huge menu! I tend to lean towards breakfast food when I go to a diner but these guys make a mean eggplant parm. Be warned, portion sizes are huge so if you're not terribly hungry, don't order that appetizer!

    They have OK wines for a diner. Nothing special. I'm glad that I can get a crown and soda here though.

  4. It is my favorite diner to go to in mamaroneck. The food is really good and they are quick in service. The nacho supremes are my favorite. But I recommend the cheese fries and chicken quesadillas. And since it is open 24 hours it is very convenient and they are open for the majority of the year.

  5. Visited this place 30 oct 2015. I must admit they did a great job with the halloween decorations… wish they could have done the same with the food.

    Ordered farmers omlette… eggs came out extremely well done and dry. The potatoes seemed under cooked. Also had the pumpkin pancakes and seemed it was heavy in the flour because the pancakes were thick to chew.  

    Buddy ordered the buffalo wings… not enough meat on the chicken.

    Service was awful… never got refills on water. Had to track them down for things I needed.

    I wouldn't recommend this place as a diner to stop by.

  6. Very sad to hear Mario, after many years is no longer working @ The Nautilus…big loss.  He was great.

  7. I have been to this diner many times. Its a good diner and I never had to wait too long for a table especially on a Sunday also. The staff is friendly and the food was served quickly! It's a 24 hour diner I have only been there for breakfast. The food was good. For it being so busy the service was prompt which was a plus.

  8. after a long ride back from Lake George, we dropped off my friend in Mamaroneck and then stopped by here for a quick meal. we weren't too hungry, but every road trip requires at least one diner stop, no?

    I had a big bowl of matzoh ball soup. standard, predictable, and exactly what I needed at the time. and they didn't skimp with the crackers. Caroline had a turkey sandwich – I had a few bites, and it was okay.

    prices are standard diner prices. Sunday night and it was actually pretty busy, but service was good.

    cool touch: they have free cookies by the register in addition to toothpicks and mints!

Rate and write a review

Boston Post Road 1240
Mamaroneck 10543 NY US
Get directions