The Stumble Inn
“Can't say a bad thing about the set-up/the drinks/prices/clientele/bartenders/etc. Beer pong is a huge win at this place too.”
“Happy hour is perfect but Tuesday night's $4 YOU CALL IT special is the best.”
“I probably ate a half pound of beef and couldn't finish the generous portion of tater tots.”
The Stumble Inn
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Happy Hour: Yes
Outdoor Seating: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range $11-30
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Came here for dinner to try the infamous stuffed burgers. It was busy as it's a Saturday night and there was a big football game on TV. The only downside was the disorganization of getting a table – it's first come first served. We waited about 10 minutes and got lucky when a table opened up.
The service was great – the waitress was very friendly and attentive. The food came out quickly:
Plain nachos appetizer: very cheesy, comes with jalapeños on top with sides of salsa and sour cream. Simple and straightforward.
The Spicy Stumbler: amazing, amazing choice. It's a huge burger stuffed with cheddar and jalapeños. I got lettuce, tomato and onions on top and it was pretty messy but delicious. The burger meat is very tender and juicy – almost melts in your mouth. I could barely finish it.
Custom burger with american cheese and sautéed onions: It was full of flavor and cooked perfectly for having a filling. You don't get a choice of how your burger is cooked it just comes medium.
The Stuffed Stumbler: Expected the bleu cheese to be melted but it stayed crumbled which was great. It was juicy and delicious.
Great stuffed burgers! It was juicy and fantastic. They have a variety of burgers like blue cheese and bacon. Their stuffed nachos are great too!
Stumbled in here after a 5k in Central Park with quite a few folks and they comfortably fit all gazillion of us. Great place for large groups!
Space – Restrooms are all the way in the back on your right. Very clean for a bar bathroom, even into the wee hours of the night.
Bartender- Quick and efficient. I walked up to the counter, waved my hand, made eye contact, mouthed my drink order, and got a drink in my hand in less than a minute.
Gin and tonic – Watered down. Tasted like I was drinking a Sprite.
Whiskey ginger – Definitely had a little more kick than the gin and tonic, albeit whiskey is an acquired taste.
Beef Fajitas – I haven't come across bar food that I loved, but these fajitas were decent. Traditional combo of beef strips, caramelized onions, and roasted peppers. Came with soft tortilla shells.
Between you and me… I secretly love this place. Shh, don't tell anybody.
Loud, lively, drunk patrons cram themselves into The Stumble Inn almost nightly. Walking by, the noises from this establishment conjure up images of frat boys doing keg stands. But me?? I'm an adult who is much too sophisticated!! I couldn't pooooooooossssssssssssssssibly like a place like thiiiiis.
But I do.
Drinks, food, bartenders… Every aspect of this place is great. They offer different drink/food specials every night of the week, which is great because they are busy just as often. Flat screens are positioned throughout, so sports fans, rejoice! It does get a little crowded at times and difficult to find a seat, but the lively atmosphere will probably keep you on your feet most of the time anyway.
In conclusion, I love The Stumble Inn!
But, shh. Don't tell anyone.
Bring cash. Super crowded so get here early for your favorite sports game. Subpar food for the price but good specials on beers. Bring cash.
It's difficult to give a rating to a place that is objectively great, but which I would not visit on my own accord. If you're missing the good old days of college shenanigans, beer pong, and cheap beer, this is the place for you. Pitchers are very inexpensive, and beer pong is free, provided you buy the beer. Patrons are very friendly and you can always find someone to play you at beer pong. The staff isn't the greatest, and they've had attitudes on multiple occasions. It can get very very loud here, but as long as you keep all of this in mind, you'll be fine.
I don't really much like coming here for a night out. It gets a little crowded and fratty. However, it's a good place to come for a casual happy hour and Sunday football. There are different happy hour specials each day of the week- you can look ahead of time on their website. On Sundays, there is half priced beer from 12PM-4AM, and there are a ton of TVs. They also open up the back room for more space/beer pong/flip cup. Fun atmosphere for watching football. I've never had the food, but my friends really like the stuffed burgers.
This was our second stop on our UES bar hop. The bar is very big and there are high tops in the center but yes it certainly has a "frat house" atmosphere. The music is blaring, ppl in the back playing beer pong are obnoxiously loud and the pours are light handed. Perhaps because most of the clientele look like they just became of legal drinking age.