Toloache
“Every single thing we ordered (margaritas, hamachi ceviche, medium guacamole, enchiladas borrachas, costilla de res) was knock out delicious.”
“Thumbs up, definitely would recommend for bottomless brunch and would like to try it for dinner.”
“Frutas Guacamole, De la calle Spicy margarita, carne asada, and the tuna ceviche.”
Toloache
Takes Reservations: Yes
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Waiter Service: Yes
Caters: Yes
PokéStop Nearby: Yes
Price range.
$$ Price range $11-30
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Good:
It's a very nicely decorated place with great service and good food selection.
We ordered Traditional guacamole which was delicious and tacos literally blew my mind. The meat was so so so good and all the ingredients were super fresh and tasty.
Bad:
Shrimp quesadilla was disappointing. We found it too gourmet, it had pieces of pineapple which in our opinion made it taste more like Hawaiian pizza.
We didn't find this placer good for drinking. No draft beers. Only small bottles of Mexican beer (pricy also, $8 per bottle!). The purpose of our visit on a beautiful Sunday morning was to eat Mexican food and drink as many margaritas as possible. However, considering the prices they charge for their margaritas, we had to rethink our strategy and have drinks elsewhere.
I recommend the bottomless brunch, if you can get a groupon or deal online (shoot for $30 or less per person). Other than that, it isn't worth it, unless you seriously plan on drinking yourself stupid. Some portions are larger than others, but beware, the meals are not sizable (sandwiches, burger, huarache are all good portions). JM Huarache is amazing, and authentic. I will definitely go back, but note: I WILL BE USING A DISCOUNT ONLINE.
Been meaning to checkout their Passover menu for a while now, so glad I finally made it this year.
The staff was attentive and everything we ordered was delicious. Some items from the regular menu and some from the special Passover-friendly menu.
Margaritas (yay for happy hour!), chips and guacamole, jicama salad, the lamb in my picture, and side of brussels sprouts were all very good.
Definitely want to come here again every Passover!
Only 4 stars because, other than the happy hour drink prices, this isn't a place I could afford to go to for dinner often.
My boyfriend and I had a wonderful dinner at Toloache. The upstairs seating is so ambient and intimate. Coupled with the decor and candlelight, it was definitely the perfect date spot. Although the dishes are a bit pricey, the food is delicious and the service seamless. I highly recommend the guacamole with fruit for an app! You will not regret it. My boyfriend said that our meal at Toloache was one of the best meals of his life!
3/5 stars for weekday lunch.
I came here for lunch with a coworker. We did not get the $16.95 lunch special because I was set on getting avocado fries for appetizers.
The entrees we had were great – I had the quesadilla with chicken and she had the carne asada tacos. Both were great and we fulfilled our craving for Mexican food. It was a bit expensive for what it was, but still decent.
We were both REALLY disappointed with the avocado fries…. It completely lacked flavor and the sauces gave the dish all the flavor, rather than complementing it. I've had MUCH better avocado fries elsewhere – I don't understand why everyone likes it here so much.
Overall, I'm not sure if I would come back here since we have other options for Mexican in the neighborhood.
We were going for a bite after Drag Queen Bingo across the street and were in the mood for tacos. They were able to seat us right away and the service was fast and appropriately attentive. Between 4 of us we had fish, grasshopper and short rib tacos, a side of plantains, Brussel sprouts and the scallop appetizer.
The best of the bunch were the scallops and the Sprouts. The grasshoppers although recommended by the waitress were not to my taste. My fish was really lacking in flavor (salt would help) but the slaw on top saved them. The plantains were a bit on the greasy side for a New York crowd.
Margaritas were fine. I like that it wasn't sweet but I got the De La Calle which was nice and spicy but cucumber had no place in that drink.
Noisy- but not too bad for a west village restaurant on a Saturday night.
For the neighborhood the bill wasn't too bad but next time I will get tacos from the truck across the street and call it a day.
I really like this place, and I can't wait to go back. I will say that I have only have the drinks (and the guacamole) but both of those things made me want to return. The service is also wonderful and on nice days they open the windows and so it's almost like you're sitting on a patio.
I came here after work with some colleagues because we were looking for a good margarita. We definitely found it both in terms of the classic as well as margaritas with a twist. Up until this point, my favorite place for a hibiscus margarita was Papatzul but this place is now neck-and-neck. Also, the guacamole is fabulous. When I saw the price tag (over $10 for guac seems excessive), I almost didn't order it but we were hungry and needed something to go with the drinks. Safe to say, I understand the price tag now because the ingredients are amazing and the taste is robust. Even though we were only there for drinks, the waitstaff was super attentive and nice the entire time.
All-in-all, I was very happy with my experience and I look forward to coming again and trying to full menu.
Food is a bit on the salty side but ppl are super nice there!
Lunch is usually not so crowded, and the lunch special with a guac, entree, and a soft drink for $16.95 is not a bad deal!
They also have great happy hours from 11:30-7!!