Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
“After taking forever to choose, I settled for a buffalo chicken slice and calamari, along with the Nutella zeppoles.”
“The delivery was fast, about 35-40 mins and the food was still hot being that I live 1 mile away from the place.”
“You'll find slices like Potato Lover, Cheese Fries, Baked Ziti, Mediterranean, Vegan Taco, Chicken Parm, the list goes on!”
Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Accepts Apple Pay: Yes
Wheelchair Accessible: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Caters: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
8 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
I came here for the first time and it literally took me 10 minutes to decide what I wanted. The menu leaves you so up in the air with all of the options listed. After taking forever to choose, I settled for a buffalo chicken slice and calamari, along with the Nutella zeppoles.
The calamari I absolutely loved! The slice was good, I like my chicken on my pizza in bigger chunks opposed to the pieces that Tony's puts on theirs. All in all it was an edible slice. The zeppoles are the devil. The devil just delivered on a plate….yummers.
I would definitely be another customer but I would most likely order in. The decor is like an old school neighborhood pizza shop, I'd rather take the food home. Since there's about 100 items on the menu I won't mind trying the other 97.
By the way… Excellent service! They guys there care about their customers' needs.
Solid pie. It's not Grimaldi's, but it's satisfying enough when you're craving some of that triangle-based goodness. Pepperoni and cheese are both good, with a proper balance of both on the slices. Crusts are a little crispy, but not bad.
The staff themselves are super friendly.
Best pizza delivery in the neighborhood. Do not confuse with the other Tony's Pizza on Knickerbocker Ave. This is the good one!
I've never actually been to the storefront itself so this review is based on deliveries only and they do that very well. I've ordered from here maybe 10 times and they are always quick and have never messed up my order. My go to is the Grandmas pie which is a square thin crust pizza with a rich chunky tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella. The kicker is that they put cloves of roasted garlic under the cheese. That right there separates the men from the boys.
Their Buffalo Chicken pizza is also spot on. Definitely heavier on the sauce (buffalo and blue cheese), I appreciate this a lot. There's really not much worse than a dry buff chic slice.
Plain slices leave something to be desired. The garlic knots are just ok. Salads are respectable. Come here for the Grandmas, Buffalo Chicken or any of their other many specialty slices. You won't be disappointed or leave hungry. Slices are BIG!
Tony's is a Bushwick staple! Been coming here for a good 10+ years.
Service is always good, deliveries are one point, and most importantly the pizza is the bomb dot com. These slices are the definition of a Brooklyn slice. But that lasagna though????? It MIGHT be better than my moms. Don't tell her I said that.
They rent the space upstairs for birthday parties and such. Not sure of the prices but the space is huge.
The lasagna slice was ok…but my BF told me that ranch slice is the way to go! Next time :-/
Their pizza is DELICIOUS. I was kind of disappointed that their lemonade wasn't available but they had delicious fresh coffee so that was good. The staff was polite and friendly. And this place is very clean. The only thing is the music they play is a little loud.. They could turn down the "elevator music" they play a little.
Delicious and authentic NY pizza. They delivered so quickly too.
This business is a scam.
I ordered pasta alio e olio for $7.25, as printed on their menu. The man ringing me up charged me $8.98 (including tax). I paid and then took a look at their menu. I confirmed the price, and let the people behind the counter know that I was overcharged.
A manager immediately appeared out of the woodwork, and proceeded to claim that they could change the prices at their discretion. He said that on the bottom of the menu that they can adjust prices as they please.
The problem is that they did not inform me of their updated price before I ordered. Nor did they list the updated price on their readerboard (the one above the counter). They didn't even have my dish listed there! Meanwhile, they continued to distribute a printed menu with information they knew to be inaccurate.
This approach is illegal, and if I encounter it again at any other establishment I will call the cops.
I insisted that I would not pay for a bait-and-switch item. I have more self-respect than that. The manager continued to lecture me and make illegitimate claims about his pricing structure. Then, in a ridiculous turn of events, a job applicant standing at the counter heaped on, claiming that I didn't read the stipulations on the menu. This was audaciously rude of someone who doesn't even work there; a good manager would have told him to be quiet and get out.
A number of people rose to his defense, gathering around me and shouting at me. I was genuinely concerned for my safety and continued walking away.
The owner proceeded to nearly initiate a fist fight with me. He displayed aggressive bullying and an immature negotiating style. He exhibited no integrity; he did not stand by his word. He demanded that I pay an arbitrary price. Getting overcharged in New York is not new; nor is getting overcharged because you look well-off. What is unique is the lengths to which the manager aggressively defended his illegal business practices, and the intensity of his visceral reaction. He is a bigger, taller, and physically stronger man than I, and he exploited this differential in an attempt to bully me into submission.
When you feel you are in physical danger over illegal business practices, you know you should stay as far as way as possible.
If you encounter a similar situation at any establishment, begin by calling the cops. If that doesn't result in a favorable outcome, file a complaint with the Department of Consumer Affairs. A business can be held liable in civil and criminal court for illegal pricing.