Tony’s Pizzeria
“Whenever I'm
In Dyker heights I drop by have a conversation with the boys and gobble
Up that yummy pizza.”
“Everyone there is great, they do curbside delivery to save you a ticket along with regular delivery too.”
“The difference to me is definitely in the quality of the cheese, an expanded menu and now they have daily specials that help them rival other top notch pizza places in the immediate area.”
Tony’s Pizzeria
Delivery: Yes
Take-out: Yes
Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
Bike Parking: Yes
Good for Kids: Yes
Good for Groups: Yes
Has TV: Yes
Caters: Yes
Price range.
$ Price range Under $10
6 reviews
Rate and write a review Cancel reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
After a night of walking around the neighborhood at the Christmas Lights Display of Dyker Heights, we were hungry, and luckily, Tony's was opened.
We grabbed two slices of piping hot fresh mozzarella slices and decided to shameless eat them on the front porch. What absolute amazingness in such a simple slice! You can taste the freshness of the basil, and the cheese was melted perfectly. No grease to be had, and the slice passed the firm crust test!
More importantly, this establishment is a family run business, and you get that vibe from walking inside and seeing family pictures on the wall. They are actually in the back or behind the register, not working remotely like so many other places you've been to. Don't hesitate to ask about the history, any of the staff will be more than happy to tell you about it.
I would love to try some of their other options during regular business hours, but hey! The Christmas Lights will be up for a few more days; I have my excuse – what's yours?
Mmmm… Brooklyn pizza. Nothing beats it. My boyfriend and I stopped at Tony's after visiting the Dyker Heights Christmas Lights displays. We kept it simple with plain slices, which were huge and everything you wish for Brooklyn pizza to be: cheese that strings a bit when you bit it, sauce that is ever so slightly sweet, perfect crunchy crust…If ever we find ourselves in the neighborhood again we will surely stop at Tony's for a slice.
Great neighborhood spot, nice staff, and and a solid vodka slice.
We got a fresh half vodka pie, and each slice was a meal of its own. The sauce was perfect, not to sweet and not to tangy and the dough held together well
Solid pizzeria overall
Get the vodka slice! Ahh so perfect. Sweet but tangy sauce, and unlike other spots in Brooklyn (*cough cough* Krispy Pizzeria), it doesn't taste like it's out of a can. I haven't tried anything else there but I really don't care. They get 4 stars for that slice.
Awesome! No other words. True Brooklyn pizza in Dyker Heights takes me back to my childhood. The perfect balance of sauce and cheese, I love it. Absolutely come here to the corner of 13th Ave and 77th St and enjoy.
If you want great service, this is the place. But to be honest, the pizza is subpar. I only go here because it's right down the street from my house. If not, I'd go to Frank's which is located two blocks away.
I wish I knew what the original place was like. Tony's took over ownership in the past year and I've so far had their regular cheese slides, the margharitas, grandma's along with a few others and if I had to rate them out of 5, with 3.5 being average, I'd have to give the taste a 3.
I've also had their lasagna special and chicken rolls. The lasagna is solid for your neighborhood pizza joint. The chicken rolls are super bready but once you get to the filling, it's pretty good. They normally don't give you a side of sauce so make sure to ask for that.
And yesterday, I was really annoyed because their credit card machine was done. So I had to spend an extra $3 on ATM fees to pay for my food. I know it's not their fault but they should have that taken care of. If I knew in advance, again, I would've went to Frank's.